{
  "counts": {
    "above_hull": 25,
    "entries": 94,
    "intervals": 6,
    "vertices": 7
  },
  "elements": [
    "NB",
    "W"
  ],
  "flags": [
    "degenerate_endpoints",
    "has_intermediate_compounds",
    "mp_agreement_not_comparable",
    "theoretical_vertices"
  ],
  "isotherms": [
    {
      "intervals": [
        {
          "intercept": 0.0,
          "kind": "two_phase",
          "left": {
            "phase": "oqmd-ref-Nb",
            "x": 0.0
          },
          "mu_a_rel": 0.0,
          "mu_b_rel": -0.11440469000000064,
          "right": {
            "phase": "oqmd-2036485",
            "x": 0.5
          },
          "slope": -0.11440469000000064,
          "x_hi": 0.5,
          "x_lo": 0.0
        },
        {
          "intercept": -0.04927476000000298,
          "kind": "two_phase",
          "left": {
            "phase": "oqmd-2036485",
            "x": 0.5
          },
          "mu_a_rel": -0.04927476000000298,
          "mu_b_rel": -0.06512992999999767,
          "right": {
            "phase": "oqmd-2160049",
            "x": 0.7142857142857143
          },
          "slope": -0.015855169999994687,
          "x_hi": 0.7142857142857143,
          "x_lo": 0.5
        },
        {
          "intercept": -0.08160430999998164,
          "kind": "two_phase",
          "left": {
            "phase": "oqmd-2160049",
            "x": 0.7142857142857143
          },
          "mu_a_rel": -0.08160430999998164,
          "mu_b_rel": -0.052198110000006195,
          "right": {
            "phase": "oqmd-1916340",
            "x": 0.75
          },
          "slope": 0.029406199999975444,
          "x_hi": 0.75,
          "x_lo": 0.7142857142857143
        },
        {
          "intercept": -0.180621649999976,
          "kind": "two_phase",
          "left": {
            "phase": "oqmd-1916340",
            "x": 0.75
          },
          "mu_a_rel": -0.180621649999976,
          "mu_b_rel": -0.019192330000008084,
          "right": {
            "phase": "oqmd-2132156",
            "x": 0.8125
          },
          "slope": 0.1614293199999679,
          "x_hi": 0.8125,
          "x_lo": 0.75
        },
        {
          "intercept": -0.21336190625002338,
          "kind": "two_phase",
          "left": {
            "phase": "oqmd-2132156",
            "x": 0.8125
          },
          "mu_a_rel": -0.21336190625002338,
          "mu_b_rel": -0.011636886249997147,
          "right": {
            "phase": "oqmd-1916336",
            "x": 0.875
          },
          "slope": 0.20172502000002623,
          "x_hi": 0.875,
          "x_lo": 0.8125
        },
        {
          "intercept": -0.2948201100000034,
          "kind": "two_phase",
          "left": {
            "phase": "oqmd-1916336",
            "x": 0.875
          },
          "mu_a_rel": -0.2948201100000034,
          "mu_b_rel": 0.0,
          "right": {
            "phase": "oqmd-ref-W",
            "x": 1.0
          },
          "slope": 0.2948201100000034,
          "x_hi": 1.0,
          "x_lo": 0.875
        }
      ],
      "temperature_K": 0.0,
      "vertices": [
        {
          "collinear": false,
          "degenerate": [
            {
              "energy": 0.0,
              "phase": "oqmd-1215170"
            },
            {
              "energy": 0.0,
              "phase": "oqmd-1521870"
            },
            {
              "energy": 0.0,
              "phase": "oqmd-1521875"
            }
          ],
          "energy": 0.0,
          "energy_per_atom": -10.094018329999999,
          "entries_at_x": 25,
          "formula": "Nb",
          "nsites": null,
          "phase": "oqmd-ref-Nb",
          "phase_kind": "structure",
          "spacegroup_number": null,
          "spacegroup_symbol": "",
          "theoretical": false,
          "x": 0.0
        },
        {
          "collinear": false,
          "degenerate": [],
          "energy": -0.05720234500000032,
          "energy_per_atom": -11.58426185,
          "entries_at_x": 11,
          "formula": "Nb1 W1",
          "nsites": 4,
          "phase": "oqmd-2036485",
          "phase_kind": "structure",
          "spacegroup_number": 227,
          "spacegroup_symbol": "Fd-3m",
          "theoretical": true,
          "x": 0.5
        },
        {
          "collinear": false,
          "degenerate": [],
          "energy": -0.06059988142857061,
          "energy_per_atom": -12.201865434285713,
          "entries_at_x": 1,
          "formula": "Nb2 W5",
          "nsites": 7,
          "phase": "oqmd-2160049",
          "phase_kind": "structure",
          "spacegroup_number": 2,
          "spacegroup_symbol": "P-1",
          "theoretical": true,
          "x": 0.7142857142857143
        },
        {
          "collinear": false,
          "degenerate": [],
          "energy": -0.05954966000000006,
          "energy_per_atom": -12.3031828875,
          "entries_at_x": 9,
          "formula": "Nb1 W3",
          "nsites": 8,
          "phase": "oqmd-1916340",
          "phase_kind": "structure",
          "spacegroup_number": 123,
          "spacegroup_symbol": "P4/mmm",
          "theoretical": true,
          "x": 0.75
        },
        {
          "collinear": false,
          "degenerate": [],
          "energy": -0.049460327500002066,
          "energy_per_atom": -12.472236985625,
          "entries_at_x": 1,
          "formula": "Nb3 W13",
          "nsites": 16,
          "phase": "oqmd-2132156",
          "phase_kind": "structure",
          "spacegroup_number": 221,
          "spacegroup_symbol": "Pm-3m",
          "theoretical": true,
          "x": 0.8125
        },
        {
          "collinear": false,
          "degenerate": [],
          "energy": -0.036852513750000426,
          "energy_per_atom": -12.6387726025,
          "entries_at_x": 1,
          "formula": "Nb1 W7",
          "nsites": 8,
          "phase": "oqmd-1916336",
          "phase_kind": "structure",
          "spacegroup_number": 123,
          "spacegroup_symbol": "P4/mmm",
          "theoretical": true,
          "x": 0.875
        },
        {
          "collinear": false,
          "degenerate": [],
          "energy": 0.0,
          "energy_per_atom": -12.960207,
          "entries_at_x": 24,
          "formula": "W",
          "nsites": null,
          "phase": "oqmd-ref-W",
          "phase_kind": "structure",
          "spacegroup_number": null,
          "spacegroup_symbol": "",
          "theoretical": false,
          "x": 1.0
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "mp_agreement": {
    "comparable": false,
    "comparable_note": "is_stable is derived by the extraction, not an upstream flag, so comparing it against a hull recomputed from the same energies tests the derivation rather than the data",
    "max_abs_delta_energy_above_hull": 8.050499999967542e-05,
    "only_mp_stable": [
      "oqmd-685533"
    ],
    "only_ours_stable": [
      "oqmd-2036485"
    ],
    "stable_sets_match": false
  },
  "provenance": {
    "above_hull_window_eV": 0.05,
    "builder_version": 1,
    "collinear_tol": 1e-12,
    "correction_model": "OQMD fit-partial ('standard' fit, applied upstream by OQMD; none added)",
    "degenerate_tol": 1e-06,
    "entry_pool": "all_nondeprecated",
    "is_stable_source": "derived",
    "observed_at": "2026-09-05T17:02:03Z",
    "snapshot_scope_elements": [],
    "snapshot_scope_kind": "full",
    "snapshot_sha256": "2a9393262c52ec35600424236c352a4cdb3291c8b25c1c6588f5e62abe8e0d8d",
    "source_release": "qmdb_v1_8_022026",
    "stability_tol": 0.0001,
    "thermo_type": "standard",
    "upstream_energy_corrections": "OQMD 'standard' fit (fit-partial of Kirklin et al. 2015): elemental reference energies of a subset of elements fitted to experimental formation enthalpies, applied by OQMD"
  },
  "reference": {
    "kind": "dft_fitted_elemental_reference_0K",
    "per": "atom",
    "temperature_K": 0.0,
    "units": "eV/atom"
  },
  "schema_version": 1,
  "system_id": "NB-W",
  "x_element": "W"
}