{"artifacts":{"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03":{"artifact":"text_passage","label":"page 10, passage 3","page":10},"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p12/text-03":{"artifact":"text_passage","label":"page 12, passage 3","page":12},"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-05":{"artifact":"text_passage","label":"page 9, passage 5","page":9},"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-06":{"artifact":"text_passage","label":"page 9, passage 6","page":9}},"cite_as":{"also_cite":["the original source of every value you use (paper_citation / paper_doi, and cited_dois for values the paper cites from earlier work)"],"bibtex":"@misc{orchid_literature_2026,\n  author    = {Arr{\\'o}yave, Raymundo and Saal, James and Shin, Dongwon},\n  title     = {{ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature}},\n  version   = {2026.10},\n  publisher = {Zenodo},\n  year      = {2026},\n  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23735569},\n  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569},\n  note      = {Version 1, machine-extracted}\n}","dataset":"literature","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23735569","license":"CC-BY-4.0","part_of":{"bibtex":"@misc{orchid_data_2026,\n  author    = {Arr{\\'o}yave, Raymundo and Saal, James and Shin, Dongwon},\n  title     = {{ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets}},\n  version   = {2026.10},\n  publisher = {Zenodo},\n  year      = {2026},\n  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23736065},\n  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065},\n  note      = {Version 1, machine-extracted}\n}","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23736065","text":"R. Arróyave, J. Saal, D. Shin, ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets (version 2026.10; Version 1, machine-extracted), Zenodo (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065","title":"ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065"},"release_tag":"v2026.10","status":"Version 1, machine-extracted: values were read by language-model readers constrained to quote their source and checked automatically, and the release was then audited on the printed pages by adversarial audits, an independent second review of fit-facing records and a preliminary human review of a frozen sample. Flags such as accepted and ESPEI-ready record screening results, not certification; known issues are listed in the release notes.","text":"R. Arróyave, J. Saal, D. Shin, ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature (version 2026.10; Version 1, machine-extracted), Zenodo (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569","title":"ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569","version":"2026.10"},"contexts":{},"elements":["MO","NB","TA"],"licence":"CC BY 4.0 (ORCHID data; quotes are short excerpts kept for verification, the publishers' copyright, not relicensed)","models":{},"note":"records[].locator.ref -> artifacts; records[].model -> models (full records: orchid-literature.jsonl.gz)","papers":{"doi:10.1007/s11837-013-0772-3":{"authors":["William Paul Huhn","Michael Widom"],"citation":"William Paul Huhn, Michael Widom, Prediction of A2 to B2 Phase Transition in the High-Entropy Alloy Mo-Nb-Ta-W, JOM 65, 1772-1779 (2013).","container":"JOM","doi":"10.1007/s11837-013-0772-3","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s11837-013-0772-3","id":"doi:10.1007/s11837-013-0772-3","kind":"cited_work","metadata_source":"crossref","roles":["cited_source"],"source_kinds":["cited_work"],"title":"Prediction of A2 to B2 Phase Transition in the High-Entropy Alloy Mo-Nb-Ta-W","year":2013},"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780":{"authors":["Enkuan Zhang","Ying Tang","Mingwen Wen","Abdulmonem Obaied","Irina Roslyakova","Lijun Zhang"],"citation":"Enkuan Zhang, Ying Tang, Mingwen Wen, Abdulmonem Obaied, Irina Roslyakova, Lijun Zhang, On phase stability of Mo-Nb-Ta-W refractory high entropy alloys, International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials 103, 105780 (2022).","container":"International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials","doi":"10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"4364d60c7dad6df8","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"On phase stability of Mo-Nb-Ta-W refractory high entropy alloys","year":2022},"doi:10.3390/e18080403":{"authors":["Fritz Körmann","Marcel Sluiter"],"citation":"Fritz Körmann, Marcel Sluiter, Interplay between Lattice Distortions, Vibrations and Phase Stability in NbMoTaW High Entropy Alloys, Entropy 18, 403 (2016).","container":"Entropy","doi":"10.3390/e18080403","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.3390/e18080403","id":"doi:10.3390/e18080403","kind":"cited_work","metadata_source":"crossref","roles":["cited_source"],"source_kinds":["cited_work"],"title":"Interplay between Lattice Distortions, Vibrations and Phase Stability in NbMoTaW High Entropy Alloys","year":2016}},"part":1,"parts":1,"records":[{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","citations_printed":["14"],"cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1007/s11837-013-0772-3","first_author":"Huhn","kind":"assessment","label":"14","paper":"doi:10.1007/s11837-013-0772-3","reference":"W. Huhn, M. Widom, Prediction of A2 to B2 phase transition in the high-entropy alloy Mo-Nb-Ta-W, JOM 65 (2013) 1772–1779.","status":"resolved","year":"2013"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"dft","before":"model","evidence":{"quote_keywords":["first-principles"]},"field":"evidence_class","gate":"G8","rule":"quote_wording_first_principles","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-23","image_sha256":"6a5c9453618d6568419e4faadb539fd5369216efa1c00c37e294fdf8816b14e6","page":10,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4364d60c7dad6df8","seen":"p.10 right col: 'Huhn and Widom [14] predicted the order/disorder transition occurred at 1654 K by Hamiltonian fit with first-principles'; Table 3 MoNbTaW 1654, method FP, ref [14].","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","evidence_class_before_gates":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["evidence_class_reclassified","state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"evidence_class_reclassified","detail":"model -> dft by quote wording","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"G8","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-23","image_sha256":"6a5c9453618d6568419e4faadb539fd5369216efa1c00c37e294fdf8816b14e6","page":10,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4364d60c7dad6df8","seen":"p.10 right col: 'Huhn and Widom [14] predicted the order/disorder transition occurred at 1654 K by Hamiltonian fit with first-principles'; Table 3 MoNbTaW 1654, method FP, ref [14].","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-G5CPC244IO","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis_gate":"quote_wording_first_principles","class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03/s02#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"Huhn and Widom [14] predicted the order/disorder transition occurred at 1654 K by Hamiltonian fit with first-principles.","quote_page":10,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":1654.0,"temperature_printed":"1654 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":50.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/T_TRANSITION","floor":50.0,"floor_unit":"K","value":50.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1654.0},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","citations_printed":["16"],"cited_sources":[{"first_author":"Kormann","kind":"unknown","label":"16","reference":"F. Kormann, A.V. Ruban, M.H.F. Sluiter, Long-ranged interactions in bcc NbMoTaW high-entropy alloys, Mater. Res. Lett. 5 (2017) 35–40.","status":"resolved","year":"2017"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"dft","before":"model","evidence":{"quote_keywords":["first-principles"]},"field":"evidence_class","gate":"G8","rule":"quote_wording_first_principles","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-23","image_sha256":"6a5c9453618d6568419e4faadb539fd5369216efa1c00c37e294fdf8816b14e6","page":10,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4364d60c7dad6df8","seen":"p.10: 'Körmann et al. [16] reported the transition temperature in MoNbTaW at 750 K by combing the first-principles calculations with Monte Carlo simulations'; Table 3: 750, 'FP, MC', [16]. First-principles-based (with MC).","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","evidence_class_before_gates":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["evidence_class_reclassified","state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"evidence_class_reclassified","detail":"model -> dft by quote wording","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"G8","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-23","image_sha256":"6a5c9453618d6568419e4faadb539fd5369216efa1c00c37e294fdf8816b14e6","page":10,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4364d60c7dad6df8","seen":"p.10: 'Körmann et al. [16] reported the transition temperature in MoNbTaW at 750 K by combing the first-principles calculations with Monte Carlo simulations'; Table 3: 750, 'FP, MC', [16]. First-principles-based (with MC).","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-GZD23E652P","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis_gate":"quote_wording_first_principles","class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03/s03#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"Later, Körmann et al. [16] reported the transition temperature in MoNbTaW at 750 K by combing the first-principles calculations with Monte Carlo simulations.","quote_page":10,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":750.0,"temperature_printed":"750 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":50.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/T_TRANSITION","floor":50.0,"floor_unit":"K","value":50.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":750.0},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","citations_printed":["17"],"cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.3390/e18080403","first_author":"Kormann","kind":"assessment","label":"17","paper":"doi:10.3390/e18080403","reference":"F. Kormann, M.H.F. Sluiter, Interplay between lattice distortions, vibrations and phase stability in NbMoTaW high entropy alloys, Entropy 18 (2016) 403.","status":"resolved","year":"2016"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-QN6UAFJQCQ","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03/s05#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"However, in their subsequent work [17], the ordering transition temperature decreased to 508 K by considering the energies of relaxation, vibrations, electronic excitations and configurational entropy.","quote_page":10,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":508.0,"temperature_printed":"508 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/T_TRANSITION","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":129,"value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":508.0},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","citations_printed":["15"],"cited_sources":[{"first_author":"Wang","kind":"assessment","label":"15","reference":"Y. Wang, M. Yan, Q. Zhu, W.Y. Wang, Y.D. Wu, X.D. Hui, R. Otis, S.L. Shang, Z.K. Liu, L.Q. Chen, Computation of entropies and phase equilibria in refractory VNb-Mo-Ta-W high-entropy alloys, Acta Mater. 143 (2017) 88–101. 15 E. Zhang et al. International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials 103 (2022) 105780","status":"resolved","year":"2022"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"dft","before":"model","evidence":{"quote_keywords":["first-principles"]},"field":"evidence_class","gate":"G8","rule":"quote_wording_first_principles","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-23","image_sha256":"6a5c9453618d6568419e4faadb539fd5369216efa1c00c37e294fdf8816b14e6","page":10,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4364d60c7dad6df8","seen":"p.10: 'Wang et al. [15] used the first-principles approach to study the phase stability of the NbMoTaW alloy, reporting the ordering phase transition temperature at 594 K'; Table 3: 594, FP, [15].","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","evidence_class_before_gates":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["evidence_class_reclassified","state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"evidence_class_reclassified","detail":"model -> dft by quote wording","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"G8","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-23","image_sha256":"6a5c9453618d6568419e4faadb539fd5369216efa1c00c37e294fdf8816b14e6","page":10,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4364d60c7dad6df8","seen":"p.10: 'Wang et al. [15] used the first-principles approach to study the phase stability of the NbMoTaW alloy, reporting the ordering phase transition temperature at 594 K'; Table 3: 594, FP, [15].","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-I76LXQ7J4A","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis_gate":"quote_wording_first_principles","class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03/s06#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"Recently, Wang et al. [15] used the first-principles approach to study the phase stability of the NbMoTaW alloy, reporting the ordering phase transition temperature at 594 K.","quote_page":10,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":594.0,"temperature_printed":"594 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":50.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/T_TRANSITION","floor":50.0,"floor_unit":"K","value":50.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":594.0},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-MPY5STQJAL","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"attribution_note":"no printed citation: the paper's own statement","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","own_work_of_paper":true},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p10/text-03/s08#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"Although no quaternary thermodynamic parameters were added in Mo-Nb-Ta-W system, the present predicted transition temperature (i.e., 572 K) shows a reasonable agreement with those reported [13,15,17].","quote_page":10,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":572.0,"temperature_printed":"572 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/T_TRANSITION","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":129,"value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":572.0},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-2BMBTFJUEA","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p12/text-03"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"attribution_note":"no printed citation: the paper's own statement","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","own_work_of_paper":true},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p12/text-03/s13#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"Specifically, the single A2 phase is stable above 559.5 K in MoNbTaW RHEA based on the empirical criterion, which has a nice consistency with the thermodynamically calculated one at 572 K.","quote_page":12,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":559.5,"temperature_printed":"559.5 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/T_TRANSITION","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":129,"value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":559.5},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","dropped_field_count":1,"espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"has_dropped_fields":true,"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-BHT3ZU6JPN","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-05"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"attribution_note":"no printed citation: the paper's own statement","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","own_work_of_paper":true},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-05/s05#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"For the equiatomic MoNbTaW RHEA, the melting point was calculated to be 3123.5 K, which is lower than the average melting temperature (Tmaver ∑ i aver = 3155.5K, where Tm = xi Tm with Tmi as the melting point of i component i).","quote_page":9,"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":3123.5,"temperature_printed":"3123.5 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/T_TRANSITION","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":129,"value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":3123.5},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-3EVN4MFQRR.619a58","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-06"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"attribution_note":"no printed citation: the paper's own statement","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","own_work_of_paper":true},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-06/s03#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"The solidus temperature (Ts) and TB2fin MoNbTaW alloy were calculated to be 3033 and 572 K, respectively, which implies that the single disordered A2 solution exists between 572 K to 3033 K in the MoNbTaW alloy, this agrees with the single A2 phase in MoNbTaW alloy being observed experimentally at 2073 K [68] and 1673 K [69].","quote_page":9,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":3033.0,"temperature_printed":"3033 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"solidus","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/T_TRANSITION","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":129,"value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":3033.0},{"chemical_system":"MO-NB-TA","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"proposed","second_reader":"pending","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":3,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-3EVN4MFQRR.63007d","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-06"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"attribution_note":"no printed citation: the paper's own statement","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","own_work_of_paper":true},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.ijrmhm.2022.105780/p9/text-06/s03#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"The solidus temperature (Ts) and TB2fin MoNbTaW alloy were calculated to be 3033 and 572 K, respectively, which implies that the single disordered A2 solution exists between 572 K to 3033 K in the MoNbTaW alloy, this agrees with the single A2 phase in MoNbTaW alloy being observed experimentally at 2073 K [68] and 1673 K [69].","quote_page":9,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"MO-NB-TA","system":"MO-NB-TA","temperature_K":572.0,"temperature_printed":"572 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/T_TRANSITION","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":129,"value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":572.0}],"release":"orchid-literature 2026-10-23 (record store db-v2.1: invariant/general v2.1.19r, text+context fixup-20261022)","system":"MO-NB-TA"}