{"artifacts":{"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2/p12/tab-v":{"artifact":"table","caption":"A Summary of Results from the First-Principles Calculations","label":"V","page":12},"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Enthalpy of formation of the different end-members in the Cr-Nb system","label":"6","page":7},"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Summary of the experimental data.","label":"1","page":3},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Enthalpies of formation at 0 K of the end-members of the stable and metastable phases of the Fe–Nb–Ni system; our final choices of enthalpies at 0 K, A of our TDB, (magnetic effect excluded for the pure elements references) for all the CEF compounds; the A deduced from our AI results; the other possible A from the literature; the magnetic moments entered in our TDB; the magnetic moment obtained from our AI calculations; the ones proposed in the literature; our AI energies at 0 K including the magnetic effect of the pure elements references; the ones from the literature. The numbers (n) are for magnetism: (1) = FM (or NFM); (2) = NM; (3) = AFM; (4) = PM.","label":"2","page":10},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Calculated total energy and structural parameters for the end-members of C14 and m with NM, FM and AFM magnetic ordering based on DFT [16]. The values in boldface show the most stable magnetic configurations. Total energies are in","label":"4","page":8},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Calculated total energy, structural parameters of Fe, Mn, and Nb, comparing with the literature data. Total energies E total are in kJ/mol-atoms, lattice parameters a","label":"5","page":9},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006/p4/tab-1":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Lattice parameters of Re, Nb, and the most stable end-members of s and χ, s-(Re) 10 (Nb) 4 (Nb) 16 χ-(Re) 24 (Nb) 10 (Re) 24 , respectively. The calculated values at 0 K are compared to previous experiments and calculations at various temperatures.","label":"1","page":4},"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Selected structural","label":"1","page":6},"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Comparison of enthalpies of formation for the end-member compounds between VASP calculations in the present work and data from the literature in the Zr-Fe-Nb system.","label":"2","page":3},"sha256:817d4718c6006e4b/p2/tab-1":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Crystal structures of phases in the Nb–Al–Si system [9]","label":"1","page":2},"sha256:89569ecc2a43917d/p5/tab-4":{"artifact":"table","caption":"G m ( u )�G m ( b ) at 0 K, DFT (QE-USPP) and CALPHAD values.","label":"4","page":5},"sha256:a43bd9e453a91e6b/p2/tab-1":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Crystal structures of phases in the Nb–Si–W system [11].","label":"1","page":2},"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-1":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Calculated and experimental lattice parameters of the SER structures","label":"1","page":3},"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Optimized structural parameters of the C14, C15 and C36 Laves phases found in this work","label":"2","page":3},"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Ab initio calculated total energy differences between the Laves phases C14, C15 and C36 and the SER states of pure constituents in comparison with data from [26]","label":"3","page":3}},"cite_as":{"also_cite":["the original source of every value you use (paper_citation / paper_doi, and cited_dois for values the paper cites from earlier work)"],"bibtex":"@misc{orchid_literature_2026,\n  author    = {Arr{\\'o}yave, Raymundo and Saal, James and Shin, Dongwon},\n  title     = {{ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature}},\n  version   = {2026.10},\n  publisher = {Zenodo},\n  year      = {2026},\n  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23735569},\n  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569},\n  note      = {Version 1, machine-extracted}\n}","dataset":"literature","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23735569","license":"CC-BY-4.0","part_of":{"bibtex":"@misc{orchid_data_2026,\n  author    = {Arr{\\'o}yave, Raymundo and Saal, James and Shin, Dongwon},\n  title     = {{ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets}},\n  version   = {2026.10},\n  publisher = {Zenodo},\n  year      = {2026},\n  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23736065},\n  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065},\n  note      = {Version 1, machine-extracted}\n}","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23736065","text":"R. Arróyave, J. Saal, D. Shin, ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets (version 2026.10; Version 1, machine-extracted), Zenodo (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065","title":"ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065"},"release_tag":"v2026.10","status":"Version 1, machine-extracted: values were read by language-model readers constrained to quote their source and checked automatically, and the release was then audited on the printed pages by adversarial audits, an independent second review of fit-facing records and a preliminary human review of a frozen sample. Flags such as accepted and ESPEI-ready record screening results, not certification; known issues are listed in the release notes.","text":"R. Arróyave, J. Saal, D. Shin, ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature (version 2026.10; Version 1, machine-extracted), Zenodo (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569","title":"ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569","version":"2026.10"},"contexts":{},"elements":["NB"],"licence":"CC BY 4.0 (ORCHID data; quotes are short excerpts kept for verification, the publishers' copyright, not relicensed)","models":{},"note":"records[].locator.ref -> artifacts; records[].model -> models (full records: orchid-literature.jsonl.gz)","papers":{"doi:10.1007/bf02665782":{"authors":["A. Bolcavage","U. R. Kattner"],"citation":"A. Bolcavage, U. R. Kattner, A reassessment of the calculated Ni-Nb phase diagram, JPE 17, 92-100 (1996).","container":"JPE","doi":"10.1007/bf02665782","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/bf02665782","id":"doi:10.1007/bf02665782","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"6466926aef8f5145","roles":["cited_source","reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"A reassessment of the calculated Ni-Nb phase diagram","year":1996},"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2":{"authors":["Chenyang Zhou","Cuiping Guo","Jingbo Li","Changrong Li","Zhenmin Du"],"citation":"Chenyang Zhou, Cuiping Guo, Jingbo Li, Changrong Li, Zhenmin Du, Key Experiments and Thermodynamic Description of the Co-Nb-Ni System, Metall Mater Trans A 51, 5892-5911 (2020).","container":"Metall Mater Trans A","doi":"10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","id":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"a58c4cb851471e14","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Key Experiments and Thermodynamic Description of the Co-Nb-Ni System","year":2020},"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y":{"authors":["Clemens Schmetterer","Alexandra Khvan","Aurélie Jacob","Bengt Hallstedt","Torsten Markus"],"citation":"Clemens Schmetterer, Alexandra Khvan, Aurélie Jacob, Bengt Hallstedt, Torsten Markus, A New Theoretical Study of the Cr-Nb System, J. Phase Equilib. Diffus. 35, 434-444 (2014).","container":"J. Phase Equilib. Diffus.","doi":"10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","id":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"764ffbfcc7694f6e","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"A New Theoretical Study of the Cr-Nb System","year":2014},"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r":{"authors":["Joaquim G. Costa Neto","Suzana G. Fries","Hans Leo Lukas","Sérgio Gama","Günter Effenberg"],"citation":"Joaquim G. Costa Neto, Suzana G. Fries, Hans Leo Lukas, Sérgio Gama, Günter Effenberg, Thermodynamic optimisation of the Nb-Cr system, Calphad 17, 219-228 (1993).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"65488995882f9a55","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Thermodynamic optimisation of the Nb-Cr system","year":1993},"doi:10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4":{"authors":["U.R Kattner","W.J Boettinger"],"citation":"U.R Kattner, W.J Boettinger, Thermodynamic calculation of the ternary TiAlNb system, Materials Science and Engineering: A 152, 9-17 (1992).","container":"Materials Science and Engineering: A","doi":"10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4","id":"doi:10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4","kind":"cited_work","metadata_source":"crossref","roles":["cited_source"],"source_kinds":["cited_work"],"title":"Thermodynamic calculation of the ternary TiAlNb system","year":1992},"doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2004.02.014":{"authors":["Yi Wang"],"citation":"Yi Wang, Thermodynamic properties of Al, Ni, NiAl, and Ni3Al from first-principles calculations, Acta Materialia (2004).","container":"Acta Materialia","doi":"10.1016/j.actamat.2004.02.014","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actamat.2004.02.014","id":"doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2004.02.014","kind":"cited_work","metadata_source":"openalex/crossref","roles":["cited_source"],"source_kinds":["cited_work"],"title":"Thermodynamic properties of Al, Ni, NiAl, and Ni3Al from first-principles calculations","year":2004},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002":{"authors":["Yi Wang"],"citation":"Yi Wang, Ab initio lattice stability in comparison with CALPHAD lattice stability, Calphad (2004).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002","id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002","kind":"cited_work","metadata_source":"openalex/crossref","roles":["cited_source"],"source_kinds":["cited_work"],"title":"Ab initio lattice stability in comparison with CALPHAD lattice stability","year":2004},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002":{"authors":["Marcel H. F. Sluiter"],"citation":"Marcel H. F. Sluiter, Ab initio lattice stabilities of some elemental complex structures, Calphad (2006).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","kind":"cited_work","metadata_source":"openalex/crossref","roles":["cited_source"],"source_kinds":["cited_work"],"title":"Ab initio lattice stabilities of some elemental complex structures","year":2006},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006":{"authors":["J. Pavlů","J. Vřešt’ál","M. Šob"],"citation":"J. Pavlů, J. Vřešt’ál, M. Šob, Re-modeling of Laves phases in the Cr–Nb and Cr–Ta systems using first-principles results, Calphad 33, 179-186 (2009).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","roles":["cited_source","reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["cited_work","journal_article"],"title":"Re-modeling of Laves phases in the Cr–Nb and Cr–Ta systems using first-principles results","year":2009},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005":{"authors":["Muriel Mathon","Damien Connétable","Bo Sundman","Jacques Lacaze"],"citation":"Muriel Mathon, Damien Connétable, Bo Sundman, Jacques Lacaze, Calphad-type assessment of the Fe–Nb–Ni ternary system, Calphad 33, 136-161 (2009).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"8546f9af08ff8ad5","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Calphad-type assessment of the Fe–Nb–Ni ternary system","year":2009},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004":{"authors":["Shuhong Liu","Bengt Hallstedt","Denis Music","Yong Du"],"citation":"Shuhong Liu, Bengt Hallstedt, Denis Music, Yong Du, Ab initio calculations and thermodynamic modeling for the Fe–Mn–Nb system, Calphad 38, 43-58 (2012).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","roles":["cited_source","reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["cited_work","journal_article"],"title":"Ab initio calculations and thermodynamic modeling for the Fe–Mn–Nb system","year":2012},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006":{"authors":["Xuan L. Liu","Chelsey Z. Hargather","Zi-Kui Liu"],"citation":"Xuan L. Liu, Chelsey Z. Hargather, Zi-Kui Liu, First-principles aided thermodynamic modeling of the Nb–Re system, Calphad 41, 119-127 (2013).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"4af8d61ffb5bc33a","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"First-principles aided thermodynamic modeling of the Nb–Re system","year":2013},"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.04.004":{"authors":["Yan Li","Changrong Li","Zhenmin Du","Cuiping Guo"],"citation":"Yan Li, Changrong Li, Zhenmin Du, Cuiping Guo, Thermodynamic optimization of the Nb–Si–W ternary system, Calphad 43, 112-123 (2013).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2013.04.004","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.calphad.2013.04.004","id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.04.004","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"a43bd9e453a91e6b","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Thermodynamic optimization of the Nb–Si–W ternary system","year":2013},"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2004.03.011":{"authors":["G. Shao"],"citation":"G. Shao, Thermodynamic assessment of the Nb–Si–Al system, Intermetallics 12, 655-664 (2004).","container":"Intermetallics","doi":"10.1016/j.intermet.2004.03.011","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2004.03.011","id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2004.03.011","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","roles":["cited_source","reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["cited_work","journal_article"],"title":"Thermodynamic assessment of the Nb–Si–Al system","year":2004},"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008":{"authors":["Hai-Jin Lu","Nan Zou","Xu-Shan Zhao","Jian-Yun Shen","Xiao-Gang Lu","Yan-Lin He"],"citation":"Hai-Jin Lu, Nan Zou, Xu-Shan Zhao, Jian-Yun Shen, Xiao-Gang Lu, Yan-Lin He, Thermodynamic investigation of the Zr-Fe-Nb system and its applications, Intermetallics 88, 91-100 (2017).","container":"Intermetallics","doi":"10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"537e6fa1d1e99d97","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Thermodynamic investigation of the Zr-Fe-Nb system and its applications","year":2017},"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251":{"authors":["Jia-Yi Yan","G.B. Olson"],"citation":"Jia-Yi Yan, G.B. Olson, Computational thermodynamics and kinetics of displacive transformations in titanium-based alloys, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 673, 441-454 (2016).","container":"Journal of Alloys and Compounds","doi":"10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","id":"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"89569ecc2a43917d","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Computational thermodynamics and kinetics of displacive transformations in titanium-based alloys","year":2016},"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7":{"authors":["G. Ghosh","A. van de Walle","M. Asta","G.B. Olson"],"citation":"G. Ghosh, A. van de Walle, M. Asta, G.B. Olson, Phase stability of the Hf-Nb system: From first-principles to CALPHAD, Calphad 26, 491-511 (2002).","container":"Calphad","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","roles":["reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Phase stability of the Hf-Nb system: From first-principles to CALPHAD","year":2002},"doi:10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9":{"authors":["A. Watson","F.H. Hayes"],"citation":"A. Watson, F.H. Hayes, Some experiences modelling the sigma phase in the Ni–V system, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 320, 199-206 (2001).","container":"Journal of Alloys and Compounds","doi":"10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9","id":"doi:10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","roles":["cited_source","reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["cited_work","journal_article"],"title":"Some experiences modelling the sigma phase in the Ni–V system","year":2001}},"part":1,"parts":1,"records":[{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CO-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["bcc(Nb)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-475EAV77KZ","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2/p12/tab-v","row":2},"method":"first-principles calculations","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","phases":[{"label":"bcc(Nb)","model_phase":"BCC_A2"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2/p12/tab-v/r02#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"MOLAR_VOLUME","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"V0","reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CO-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.906},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.5436,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.5436},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3/atom","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3/atom","unit_basis":"column_header","unit_printed":"Å3/atom","value":18.12,"value_printed":18.12},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CO-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["(Co,Ni)Nb"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-YR444HDFCU.2530e8","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2/p12/tab-v","row":19},"method":"first-principles calculations","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","phases":[{"label":"(Co,Ni)Nb"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2/p12/tab-v/r19#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔHf","reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CO":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"HCP_A3"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NI":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"FCC_A1"}},"source_system":"CO-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.848105},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","unit_basis":"column_header","unit_printed":"kJ/mol atom-1","unit_stored":"J/mol-atom","value":16.9621,"value_printed":16.9621,"value_stored":16962.1},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CO-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["(Co,Ni)Nb"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-YR444HDFCU.d9b0a7","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2/p12/tab-v","row":19},"method":"first-principles calculations","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2","phases":[{"label":"(Co,Ni)Nb"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11661-020-05963-2/p12/tab-v/r19#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"MOLAR_VOLUME","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"V0","reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CO-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.917},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.5502,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.5502},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3/atom","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3/atom","unit_basis":"column_header","unit_printed":"Å3/atom","value":18.34,"value_printed":18.34},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"Nb2:Nb","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"doi":"10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","locator":{"artifact":"table","asset":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","caption":"Enthalpy of formation of the different end-members in the Cr-Nb system","label":"6","page":7,"row":16},"pdf_page":7,"pdf_sha256":"764ffbfcc7694f6e50400cfa73eb2e7696b5c61b8d146422af81de26e7268b03","printed_phase_text":"Nb2:Nb","rationale":"Table 6 explicit endmember group labels; these are C15 model endmembers including hypothetical configurations, not newly identified stable compounds. FM/NM distinctions remain in original metadata.","rendered_page_sha256":"a187d18f2d212babc82d048ac47a0f60a7ccf3fac7d7bcd836c0aa1f5740d10c","report_id":"ORCHID-PR-20261027-v1","review_group":55,"table":"6"},"field":"phases","gate":"PR20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_placeholder_recovery","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Codex rendered-page inspection","image_sha256":"a187d18f2d212babc82d048ac47a0f60a7ccf3fac7d7bcd836c0aa1f5740d10c","method":"Explicit printed row or bounded table group; no composition or diagram inference","page":7,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"764ffbfcc7694f6e","seen":"Nb2:Nb","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":null,"before":"state_phases_missing","evidence":{"basis":"phases recovered on the printed page","evidence_id":"ORCHID-PR-20261027-v1"},"field":"gate_failures","gate":"PR20261027","rule":"placeholder_recovery_lifts_state_phases_missing"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"espei_ready_before_gates":true,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["human_review_residual_concern"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["placeholder_recovery_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"human_review_residual_concern","detail":"Phase labels only. Preserve all original scientific and state qualifications; downstream gates and ESPEI revalidation required. Table 6 explicit endmember group labels; these are C15 model endmembers including hypothetical configurations, not newly identified stable compounds. FM/NM distinctions remain in original metadata.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"PR20261027"}],"id":"ORC-XFMFG5NJ7G","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","row":16},"method":"Ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","phases":[{"label":"Nb2:Nb","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6/r16#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpies of formation","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.7665},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","unit_basis":"printed_unit","unit_printed":"kJ.mol^-1.atom^-1","unit_stored":"J/mol-atom","value":15.33,"value_printed":15.33,"value_stored":15330.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-W4FWIMABUF","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","row":16},"method":"Ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","phases":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6/r16#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"a","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.387},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0774,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0774},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":7.74,"value_printed":7.74,"value_stored":7.74},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","first_author":"Pavlu","kind":"assessment","label":"8","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","reference":"J. Pavlu, J. Vrest’al, and P. Sob, Re-modeling of Laves Phases in the Cr-Nb and Cr-Ta Systems Using First-Principles Results, CALPHAD, 2009, 33, p 179-186","status":"resolved","year":"2009"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"Nb2:Nb","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"doi":"10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","locator":{"artifact":"table","asset":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","caption":"Enthalpy of formation of the different end-members in the Cr-Nb system","label":"6","page":7,"row":17},"pdf_page":7,"pdf_sha256":"764ffbfcc7694f6e50400cfa73eb2e7696b5c61b8d146422af81de26e7268b03","printed_phase_text":"Nb2:Nb","rationale":"Table 6 explicit endmember group labels; these are C15 model endmembers including hypothetical configurations, not newly identified stable compounds. FM/NM distinctions remain in original metadata.","rendered_page_sha256":"a187d18f2d212babc82d048ac47a0f60a7ccf3fac7d7bcd836c0aa1f5740d10c","report_id":"ORCHID-PR-20261027-v1","review_group":55,"table":"6"},"field":"phases","gate":"PR20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_placeholder_recovery","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Codex rendered-page inspection","image_sha256":"a187d18f2d212babc82d048ac47a0f60a7ccf3fac7d7bcd836c0aa1f5740d10c","method":"Explicit printed row or bounded table group; no composition or diagram inference","page":7,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"764ffbfcc7694f6e","seen":"Nb2:Nb","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":null,"before":"state_phases_missing","evidence":{"basis":"phases recovered on the printed page","evidence_id":"ORCHID-PR-20261027-v1"},"field":"gate_failures","gate":"PR20261027","rule":"placeholder_recovery_lifts_state_phases_missing"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"espei_ready_before_gates":true,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["human_review_residual_concern"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["placeholder_recovery_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"human_review_residual_concern","detail":"Phase labels only. Preserve all original scientific and state qualifications; downstream gates and ESPEI revalidation required. Table 6 explicit endmember group labels; these are C15 model endmembers including hypothetical configurations, not newly identified stable compounds. FM/NM distinctions remain in original metadata.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"PR20261027"}],"id":"ORC-7SDDUNMFWD","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","row":17},"method":"Ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","phases":[{"label":"Nb2:Nb","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6/r17#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpies of formation","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.81},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","unit_basis":"printed_unit","unit_printed":"kJ.mol^-1.atom^-1","unit_stored":"J/mol-atom","value":16.2,"value_printed":16.2,"value_stored":16200.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","first_author":"Pavlu","kind":"assessment","label":"8","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","reference":"J. Pavlu, J. Vrest’al, and P. Sob, Re-modeling of Laves Phases in the Cr-Nb and Cr-Ta Systems Using First-Principles Results, CALPHAD, 2009, 33, p 179-186","status":"resolved","year":"2009"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-6CKPDM6X7F","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","row":17},"method":"Ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","phases":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6/r17#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"a","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.3845},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0769,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0769},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":7.69,"value_printed":7.69,"value_stored":7.69},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","first_author":"Sluiter","kind":"assessment","label":"55","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","reference":"M.H.F. Sluiter, Ab Initio Lattice Stabilities of Some Elemental Complex Structures, CALPHAD, 2006, 30, p 357-366","status":"resolved","year":"2006"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"Nb2:Nb","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"doi":"10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","locator":{"artifact":"table","asset":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","caption":"Enthalpy of formation of the different end-members in the Cr-Nb system","label":"6","page":7,"row":18},"pdf_page":7,"pdf_sha256":"764ffbfcc7694f6e50400cfa73eb2e7696b5c61b8d146422af81de26e7268b03","printed_phase_text":"Nb2:Nb","rationale":"Table 6 explicit endmember group labels; these are C15 model endmembers including hypothetical configurations, not newly identified stable compounds. FM/NM distinctions remain in original metadata.","rendered_page_sha256":"a187d18f2d212babc82d048ac47a0f60a7ccf3fac7d7bcd836c0aa1f5740d10c","report_id":"ORCHID-PR-20261027-v1","review_group":55,"table":"6"},"field":"phases","gate":"PR20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_placeholder_recovery","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Codex rendered-page inspection","image_sha256":"a187d18f2d212babc82d048ac47a0f60a7ccf3fac7d7bcd836c0aa1f5740d10c","method":"Explicit printed row or bounded table group; no composition or diagram inference","page":7,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"764ffbfcc7694f6e","seen":"Nb2:Nb","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":null,"before":"state_phases_missing","evidence":{"basis":"phases recovered on the printed page","evidence_id":"ORCHID-PR-20261027-v1"},"field":"gate_failures","gate":"PR20261027","rule":"placeholder_recovery_lifts_state_phases_missing"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["human_review_residual_concern"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","placeholder_recovery_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"human_review_residual_concern","detail":"Phase labels only. Preserve all original scientific and state qualifications; downstream gates and ESPEI revalidation required. Table 6 explicit endmember group labels; these are C15 model endmembers including hypothetical configurations, not newly identified stable compounds. FM/NM distinctions remain in original metadata.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"PR20261027"}],"id":"ORC-KEY7UGCFQU","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6","row":18},"method":"Ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"computed","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","paper_id":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y","phases":[{"label":"Nb2:Nb","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1007/s11669-014-0313-y/p7/tab-6/r18#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpies of formation","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.81},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-atom","unit_basis":"printed_unit","unit_printed":"kJ.mol^-1.atom^-1","unit_stored":"J/mol-atom","value":16.2,"value_printed":16.2,"value_stored":16200.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"69Rud","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["solidus"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-2JZ6NCFMEJ","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1","row":8},"method":"Incipient Melting","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","phases":[{"label":"solidus"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1/r08#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","reaction":{"printed":"Nb-solidus","type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":1973.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"1973","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"solidus","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":16.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[10.483565,26.208913],"class":"metallography_microscopy","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/unknown","floor":16.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":274,"value":16.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1973.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"61Zak","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["other"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (placeholder phases only (other))","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-6YBELMWZSI","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1","row":15},"method":"X-Ray Diffraction","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","phases":[{"label":"other"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1/r15#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","reaction":{"printed":"Nb-solvus","type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":1473.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"1473","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":16.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[10.483565,26.208913],"class":"xrd","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/unknown","floor":16.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":274,"value":16.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1473.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"61Gol","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["other"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (placeholder phases only (other))","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-NYJ4FH5HEH","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1","row":19},"method":"X-Ray Diffraction","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","phases":[{"label":"other"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1/r19#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","reaction":{"printed":"Nb-solvus","type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":1273.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"1273 and 1873","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":16.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[10.483565,26.208913],"class":"xrd","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/unknown","floor":16.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":274,"value":16.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1273.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"61Gol","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["other"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (placeholder phases only (other))","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-QNRXKNHMRG","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1","row":20},"method":"X-Ray Diffraction","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","phases":[{"label":"other"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1/r20#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","reaction":{"printed":"Nb-solvus","type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":1873.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"1273 and 1873","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":16.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[10.483565,26.208913],"class":"xrd","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/unknown","floor":16.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":274,"value":16.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1873.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"56Ely","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["solidus"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-6CRNUHT7WU","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1","row":43},"method":"Thermal Analysis","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","phases":[{"label":"solidus"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1/r43#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","reaction":{"printed":"Nb-solidus","type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":2168.0,"temperature_basis":"printed_range","temperature_printed":"1943–2393","temperature_range_K":{"max":2393.0,"min":1943.0,"printed":"1943–2393"},"temperature_uncertainty":{"basis":"printed_range","value":225.0},"tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"solidus","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":225.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"cleaned_below_threshold","ci95":[2.096713,58.183787],"class":"thermal_analysis","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/thermal_analysis","floor":5.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":9,"prior_source":"orchid_assumed","value":5.0},"sigma_printed":{"kind":"range_half_width","taken_as":"half-width","value":225.0},"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":2168.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"56Ely","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["other"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (placeholder phases only (other))","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-VDPJFFDMZW","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1","row":46},"method":"Microhardness","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","phases":[{"label":"other"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1/r46#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","reaction":{"printed":"Nb-solvus","type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":1773.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"1773 and 1933","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"experimental_unspecified","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/experimental_unspecified","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":0,"prior_source":"orchid_assumed","value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1773.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"56Ely","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["other"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (placeholder phases only (other))","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-LY66JEU52L","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1","row":47},"method":"Microhardness","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r","phases":[{"label":"other"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/0364-5916(93)90001-r/p3/tab-1/r47#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","reaction":{"printed":"Nb-solvus","type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":1933.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"1773 and 1933","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":10.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"experimental_unspecified","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/experimental_unspecified","floor":10.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":0,"prior_source":"orchid_assumed","value":10.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1933.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1007/bf02665782","first_author":"Bolcavage","kind":"assessment","label":"17","paper":"doi:10.1007/bf02665782","reference":"A. Bolcavage, U.R. Kattner, J. Phase Equilibria 17 (1996) 92–100.","status":"resolved","year":"1996"},{"first_author":"Coelho","kind":"unknown","label":"15","reference":"G.C. Coelho, S.G. Fries, H.L. Lukas, P. Majewski, J.M. Zelaya Bejarano, S. Gamma, C.A. Ribeiro, G. Effenberg, Klaus Schulze Symp. Process. Appl., High Purity Refract. Met. Alloys, Proc. Symp. Meeting in 1993, 1994, pp. 51–70.","status":"resolved","year":"1994"},{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","first_author":"Sluiter","kind":"assessment","label":"96","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","reference":"M.H.F. Sluiter, CALPHAD 30 (2006) 357–366.","status":"resolved","year":"2006"}],"conditions":{"kind":"own_work_origin_unspecified"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["D8_5"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"unspecified","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","row_state":"awaiting_reader","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-VJBNDF5PVE.33ef00","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2","row":1},"merged_ids":["ORC-VJBNDF5PVE.75a730"],"observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_kind_unstated_modelling_paper","class":"unspecified","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","phases":[{"label":"D8_5"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2/r01#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔH (AI ref GHSER, FM)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NI":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"FCC_A1"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":10.4672},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":3.5,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[2.41122,4.298262],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/HM_FORM/classes/unknown","floor":3.5,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":290,"value":3.5},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"J/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":209.344,"value_printed":209344,"value_stored":209344.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1007/bf02665782","first_author":"Bolcavage","kind":"assessment","label":"17","paper":"doi:10.1007/bf02665782","reference":"A. Bolcavage, U.R. Kattner, J. Phase Equilibria 17 (1996) 92–100.","status":"resolved","year":"1996"},{"first_author":"Coelho","kind":"unknown","label":"15","reference":"G.C. Coelho, S.G. Fries, H.L. Lukas, P. Majewski, J.M. Zelaya Bejarano, S. Gamma, C.A. Ribeiro, G. Effenberg, Klaus Schulze Symp. Process. Appl., High Purity Refract. Met. Alloys, Proc. Symp. Meeting in 1993, 1994, pp. 51–70.","status":"resolved","year":"1994"},{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","first_author":"Sluiter","kind":"assessment","label":"96","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","reference":"M.H.F. Sluiter, CALPHAD 30 (2006) 357–366.","status":"resolved","year":"2006"}],"conditions":{"kind":"own_work_origin_unspecified"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["D8_5"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"unspecified","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","row_state":"awaiting_reader","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-VJBNDF5PVE.a2241b","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2","row":1},"observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_kind_unstated_modelling_paper","class":"unspecified","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","phases":[{"label":"D8_5"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2/r01#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"A (TDB)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NI":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"FCC_A1"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":3.25},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":3.5,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[2.41122,4.298262],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/HM_FORM/classes/unknown","floor":3.5,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":290,"value":3.5},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"J/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":65.0,"value_printed":65000,"value_stored":65000.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1007/bf02665782","first_author":"Bolcavage","kind":"assessment","label":"17","paper":"doi:10.1007/bf02665782","reference":"A. Bolcavage, U.R. Kattner, J. Phase Equilibria 17 (1996) 92–100.","status":"resolved","year":"1996"}],"conditions":{"kind":"own_work_origin_unspecified"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["D0_a"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"unspecified","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-33ACS7J253.0e388d","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2","row":5},"merged_ids":["ORC-33ACS7J253.487db7"],"observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_kind_unstated_modelling_paper","class":"unspecified","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","phases":[{"label":"D0_a"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2/r05#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔH (AI ref GHSER)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NI":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"FCC_A1"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":3.7474},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":3.5,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[2.41122,4.298262],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/HM_FORM/classes/unknown","floor":3.5,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":290,"value":3.5},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"J/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":74.948,"value_printed":74948,"value_stored":74948.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1007/bf02665782","first_author":"Bolcavage","kind":"assessment","label":"17","paper":"doi:10.1007/bf02665782","reference":"A. Bolcavage, U.R. Kattner, J. Phase Equilibria 17 (1996) 92–100.","status":"resolved","year":"1996"}],"conditions":{"kind":"own_work_origin_unspecified"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["D0_a"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"unspecified","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-33ACS7J253.418e48","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2","row":5},"observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_kind_unstated_modelling_paper","class":"unspecified","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","phases":[{"label":"D0_a"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2/r05#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"A (TDB)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NI":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"FCC_A1"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":1.0},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":3.5,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[2.41122,4.298262],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/HM_FORM/classes/unknown","floor":3.5,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":290,"value":3.5},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"J/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":20.0,"value_printed":20000,"value_stored":20000.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4","first_author":"Kattner","kind":"assessment","label":"49","paper":"doi:10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4","reference":"U.R. Kattner, W.J. Boettinger, Mater. Sci. Eng. A152 (1992) 9–17.","status":"resolved","year":"1992"},{"doi":"10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9","first_author":"Watson","kind":"assessment","label":"50","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9","reference":"A. Watson, F.H. Hayes, J. Alloys Compd. 320 (2001) 199–206.","status":"resolved","year":"2001"}],"conditions":{"kind":"own_work_origin_unspecified"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["D0_22"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"unspecified","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","row_state":"awaiting_reader","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-FMD73H7SSC.15f9b2","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2","row":14},"observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_kind_unstated_modelling_paper","class":"unspecified","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","phases":[{"label":"D0_22"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2/r14#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"A (TDB)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NI":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"FCC_A1"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":1.0},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":3.5,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[2.41122,4.298262],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/HM_FORM/classes/unknown","floor":3.5,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":290,"value":3.5},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"J/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":20.0,"value_printed":20000,"value_stored":20000.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4","first_author":"Kattner","kind":"assessment","label":"49","paper":"doi:10.1016/0921-5093(92)90039-4","reference":"U.R. Kattner, W.J. Boettinger, Mater. Sci. Eng. A152 (1992) 9–17.","status":"resolved","year":"1992"},{"doi":"10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9","first_author":"Watson","kind":"assessment","label":"50","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0925-8388(00)01472-9","reference":"A. Watson, F.H. Hayes, J. Alloys Compd. 320 (2001) 199–206.","status":"resolved","year":"2001"}],"conditions":{"kind":"own_work_origin_unspecified"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-NI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"phases":["D0_22"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"unspecified","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","row_state":"awaiting_reader","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-FMD73H7SSC.4fa14d","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2","row":14},"merged_ids":["ORC-FMD73H7SSC.b9673d"],"observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_kind_unstated_modelling_paper","class":"unspecified","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"NI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005","phases":[{"label":"D0_22"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.10.005/p10/tab-2/r14#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔH (AI ref GHSER, FM)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NI":{"fixed_state_variables":{"T":298.15},"phase":"FCC_A1"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-NI","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.01395},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":3.5,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[2.41122,4.298262],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/HM_FORM/classes/unknown","floor":3.5,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":290,"value":3.5},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"J/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":0.279,"value_printed":279,"value_stored":279.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","pdf_page":8,"pdf_sha256":"cfecab996b1fcdb98f8704d34f1aad875e05a4c72fa56fc2e3766b2bec473e3c","printed":"Structure: C14 (first row of block: C14 NbMn2 NM -913.923 4.802 7.930 158.4)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19],"table":"4","table_key":"t004"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"7736eb11fb391ed9d5613d83df9047ba99daf7ba872b2b974cf463c6dc521e5a","page":8,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"cfecab996b1fcdb9","seen":"C14 block = NbMn2, MnNb2, MnMn2, NbNb2, NbFe2, FeNb2, FeFe2; ends before the μ block (Fe7Nb6)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DZHKMVKZ5P.43df50","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":10},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r10#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","structure":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.08869,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.08869},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":8.869,"value_stored":8.869},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","pdf_page":8,"pdf_sha256":"cfecab996b1fcdb98f8704d34f1aad875e05a4c72fa56fc2e3766b2bec473e3c","printed":"Structure: C14 (first row of block: C14 NbMn2 NM -913.923 4.802 7.930 158.4)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19],"table":"4","table_key":"t004"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"7736eb11fb391ed9d5613d83df9047ba99daf7ba872b2b974cf463c6dc521e5a","page":8,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"cfecab996b1fcdb9","seen":"C14 block = NbMn2, MnNb2, MnMn2, NbNb2, NbFe2, FeNb2, FeFe2; ends before the μ block (Fe7Nb6)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DZHKMVKZ5P.930c38","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":10},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r10#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V0","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","structure":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":6.888,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":6.888},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3","value":229.6},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","pdf_page":8,"pdf_sha256":"cfecab996b1fcdb98f8704d34f1aad875e05a4c72fa56fc2e3766b2bec473e3c","printed":"Structure: C14 (first row of block: C14 NbMn2 NM -913.923 4.802 7.930 158.4)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19],"table":"4","table_key":"t004"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"7736eb11fb391ed9d5613d83df9047ba99daf7ba872b2b974cf463c6dc521e5a","page":8,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"cfecab996b1fcdb9","seen":"C14 block = NbMn2, MnNb2, MnMn2, NbNb2, NbFe2, FeNb2, FeFe2; ends before the μ block (Fe7Nb6)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DZHKMVKZ5P.a3e307","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":10},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r10#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","structure":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05467,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.05467},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":5.467,"value_stored":5.467},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","pdf_page":8,"pdf_sha256":"cfecab996b1fcdb98f8704d34f1aad875e05a4c72fa56fc2e3766b2bec473e3c","printed":"Structure: C14 (first row of block: C14 NbMn2 NM -913.923 4.802 7.930 158.4)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19],"table":"4","table_key":"t004"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"7736eb11fb391ed9d5613d83df9047ba99daf7ba872b2b974cf463c6dc521e5a","page":8,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"cfecab996b1fcdb9","seen":"C14 block = NbMn2, MnNb2, MnMn2, NbNb2, NbFe2, FeNb2, FeFe2; ends before the μ block (Fe7Nb6)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DZHKMVKZ5P.f86d0f","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":10},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r10#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V0","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","structure":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":6.888,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":6.888},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3 per formula unit","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3 per formula unit","value":229.6},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["μ"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-THLWLDVIFI.0df1ab","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":34},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"μ"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r34#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V0","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":22.29,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":22.29},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3 per formula unit","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3 per formula unit","value":743.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["μ"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-THLWLDVIFI.244a63","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":34},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"μ"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r34#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V0","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":22.29,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":22.29},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3","value":743.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["μ"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-THLWLDVIFI.989d9e","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":34},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"μ"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r34#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05456,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.05456},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":5.456,"value_stored":5.456},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["μ"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-THLWLDVIFI.d486d6","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4","row":34},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"μ"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p8/tab-4/r34#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.2883,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.2883},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":28.825,"value_stored":28.825},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["(Nb)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:T_K_explicit","temperature not stated"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-OI4SYKUVUN.5a0b74","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5","row":7},"model_unlinked_reason":"linked TDB not the reporting paper's own model (link basis: None)","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"caption_names_calculation_only","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"(Nb)"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5/r07#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V0","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_basis":"not_printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.183,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/VOLUME","floor":0.005,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":0,"value":0.183},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3","value":36.6},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["(Nb)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:T_K_explicit","temperature not stated"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-OI4SYKUVUN.99a902","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5","row":7},"model_unlinked_reason":"linked TDB not the reporting paper's own model (link basis: None)","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"caption_names_calculation_only","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"(Nb)"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5/r07#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_basis":"not_printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.02556,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.005826,0.012707],"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.0077,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":175,"value":0.02556},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":3.32,"value_stored":3.32},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002","first_author":"Wang","kind":"assessment","label":"78","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002","reference":"Y. Wang, S. Curtarolo, C. Jiang, R. Arroyave, T. Wang, G. Ceder, L.-Q. Chen, Z.K. Liu, Calphad 28 (2004) 79–90.","status":"resolved","year":"2004"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["(Nb)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:T_K_explicit","temperature not stated"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-AJA5CODC2X.4198f5","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5","row":8},"model_unlinked_reason":"linked TDB not the reporting paper's own model (link basis: None)","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"caption_names_calculation_only","class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"(Nb)"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5/r08#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_basis":"not_printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.02558,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.005826,0.012707],"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.0077,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":175,"value":0.02558},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":3.322,"value_stored":3.322},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002","first_author":"Wang","kind":"assessment","label":"78","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2004.05.002","reference":"Y. Wang, S. Curtarolo, C. Jiang, R. Arroyave, T. Wang, G. Ceder, L.-Q. Chen, Z.K. Liu, Calphad 28 (2004) 79–90.","status":"resolved","year":"2004"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-MN-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"phases":["(Nb)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:T_K_explicit","temperature not stated"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":1,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-AJA5CODC2X.452f7d","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5","row":8},"model_unlinked_reason":"linked TDB not the reporting paper's own model (link basis: None)","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"caption_names_calculation_only","class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"MN":0.0,"NB":1.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","phases":[{"label":"(Nb)"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004/p9/tab-5/r08#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V0","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-MN-NB","system":"NB","temperature_basis":"not_printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.1835,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/VOLUME","floor":0.005,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":0,"value":0.1835},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å3","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å3","value":36.7},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"NB-RE","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":{"RE":0.0},"phases":["Nb (bcc)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"Nb (bcc)","space_group":"Im-3m"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_07","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","pdf_page":4,"pdf_sha256":"4af8d61ffb5bc33abfb2d1ae216cef886ae11e4ca1e74fa2ef3b74daa7ea2dd9","printed":"Nb (bcc) | Im3̄m | a 3.317, 3.322, 3.30 (Present work, DFT [36], Experiment [34])","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies space_group; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[4,5,6],"table":"1","table_key":"t129"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 07","image_sha256":"1fd2db9196011ef12fe76f796e542abcab033c64afeca7fb28c2162fbfe68d66","page":4,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4af8d61ffb5bc33a","seen":"Nb (bcc) group, 3 source lines; ends before the σ end-member row","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-M6YDKDLVX3","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006/p4/tab-1","row":4},"observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_uncited_beside_cited_rows+title_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"RE":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","phases":[{"label":"Nb (bcc)"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006/p4/tab-1/r04#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"NB-RE","structure":{"phase":"Nb (bcc)","space_group":"Im-3m"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.03317,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.03317},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":3.317,"value_stored":3.317},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.actamat.2004.02.014","first_author":"Wang","kind":"assessment","label":"36","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.actamat.2004.02.014","reference":"Y. Wang, S. Curtarolo, C. Jiang, R. Arroyave, T. Wang, G. Ceder, L.Q. Chen, Z. K. Liu, CALPHAD 28 (2004) 79–90.","status":"resolved","year":"2004"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"NB-RE","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":{"RE":0.0},"phases":["Nb (bcc)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"Nb (bcc)","space_group":"Im-3m"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_07","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","pdf_page":4,"pdf_sha256":"4af8d61ffb5bc33abfb2d1ae216cef886ae11e4ca1e74fa2ef3b74daa7ea2dd9","printed":"Nb (bcc) | Im3̄m | a 3.317, 3.322, 3.30 (Present work, DFT [36], Experiment [34])","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies space_group; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[4,5,6],"table":"1","table_key":"t129"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 07","image_sha256":"1fd2db9196011ef12fe76f796e542abcab033c64afeca7fb28c2162fbfe68d66","page":4,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4af8d61ffb5bc33a","seen":"Nb (bcc) group, 3 source lines; ends before the σ end-member row","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-XUK5EQBGQO","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006/p4/tab-1","row":5},"observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"computed","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"RE":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","phases":[{"label":"Nb (bcc)"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006/p4/tab-1/r05#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"NB-RE","structure":{"phase":"Nb (bcc)","space_group":"Im-3m"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.03322,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.03322},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":3.322,"value_stored":3.322},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"first_author":"Kittel","kind":"unknown","label":"34","reference":"C. Kittel, Introduction to Solid State Physics, Wiley, New York, 1995, p. 688.","status":"resolved","year":"1995"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":null,"before":0.0,"evidence":{"caption":"Lattice parameters of Re, Nb, and the most stable end-members of s and χ, s-(Re) 10 (Nb) 4 (Nb) 16 χ-(Re) 24 (Nb) 10 (Re) 24 , respectively. The calculated valu","why":"0 K is the temperature of the first-principles columns of the table, not of this cited experimental value; formation quantities are standard (298.15 K), others unstated"},"field":"temperature_K","gate":"R2","rule":"experimental_value_from_0K_caption","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-24","image_sha256":"797bae5146d08da7016bcf863d95822304e3e45ac67e031a49aad7fa228cf482","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"664f945fea949860","seen":"Cited experimental values in tables captioned 0 K / first-principles took 0 K; formation quantities are standard (298.15 K), ambient when the caption says so, unstated otherwise.","verdict":"rule_confirmed"}},{"after":"NB","before":"NB-RE","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":{"RE":0.0},"phases":["Nb (bcc)"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"Nb (bcc)","space_group":"Im-3m"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_07","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","pdf_page":4,"pdf_sha256":"4af8d61ffb5bc33abfb2d1ae216cef886ae11e4ca1e74fa2ef3b74daa7ea2dd9","printed":"Nb (bcc) | Im3̄m | a 3.317, 3.322, 3.30 (Present work, DFT [36], Experiment [34])","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies space_group; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[4,5,6],"table":"1","table_key":"t129"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 07","image_sha256":"1fd2db9196011ef12fe76f796e542abcab033c64afeca7fb28c2162fbfe68d66","page":4,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"4af8d61ffb5bc33a","seen":"Nb (bcc) group, 3 source lines; ends before the σ end-member row","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-SDHTHO4HJX","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006/p4/tab-1","row":6},"observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"RE":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006","phases":[{"label":"Nb (bcc)"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.02.006/p4/tab-1/r06#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"NB-RE","structure":{"phase":"Nb (bcc)","space_group":"Im-3m"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":null,"temperature_K_stored":0.0,"temperature_basis":"not_printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.001793,0.002549],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/LATTICE_LENGTH/classes/unknown","floor":0.0022,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":586,"value":0.00726},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":3.3,"value_stored":3.3},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"HF-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"phases","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"before":{"strukturbericht":"A2"},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-UJNER7X26S","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1","row":7},"method":"ab-initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","phases":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1/r07#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"HF-NB","structure":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.03293,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.03293},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":3.2929,"value_stored":0.32929},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"1964Val","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"HF-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"phases","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-SWHBONND3X","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1","row":8},"observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","phases":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1/r08#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"single_reader_text_layer","reader_agreement_label":"single reader + PDF text layer","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"HF-NB","structure":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":4.2,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"4.2 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.007265,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.001793,0.002549],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/LATTICE_LENGTH/classes/unknown","floor":0.0022,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":586,"value":0.007265},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":3.3024,"value_stored":0.33024},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"HF-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"FCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'FCC (A1)' | 0.41999","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[9],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"phases","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block FCC row","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":{"phase":"FCC","strukturbericht":"A1"},"before":{"strukturbericht":"A1"},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'FCC (A1)' | 0.41999","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[9],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block FCC row","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-EMJ7BGJRNV","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1","row":9},"method":"ab-initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","phases":[{"label":"FCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1/r09#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"HF-NB","structure":{"phase":"FCC","strukturbericht":"A1"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.042,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.042},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":4.1999,"value_stored":0.41999},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"HF-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"HCP","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'HCP (A3)' | a=0.28453 c=0.52551","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[10],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"phases","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block HCP row","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":{"phase":"HCP","strukturbericht":"A3"},"before":{"strukturbericht":"A3"},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'HCP (A3)' | a=0.28453 c=0.52551","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[10],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block HCP row","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-YPKUFFKRWL.56d115","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1","row":10},"method":"ab-initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","phases":[{"label":"HCP","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1/r10#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"HF-NB","structure":{"phase":"HCP","strukturbericht":"A3"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05255,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.05255},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":5.2551,"value_stored":0.52551},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"HF-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"HCP","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'HCP (A3)' | a=0.28453 c=0.52551","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[10],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"phases","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block HCP row","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":{"phase":"HCP","strukturbericht":"A3"},"before":{"strukturbericht":"A3"},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'HCP (A3)' | a=0.28453 c=0.52551","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[10],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block HCP row","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-YPKUFFKRWL.b8d7ea","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1","row":10},"method":"ab-initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","phases":[{"label":"HCP","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1/r10#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"HF-NB","structure":{"phase":"HCP","strukturbericht":"A3"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.02845,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.02845},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":2.8453,"value_stored":0.28453},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"paper_context_not_extracted","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"HF-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"phases","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-RDQFC6NKXO","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1","row":12},"method":"Expt.","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","phases":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1/r12#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"single_reader_text_layer","reader_agreement_label":"single reader + PDF text layer","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"HF-NB","structure":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":4.2,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"4.2 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.004293,"sigma_method":{"basis":"cleaned_below_threshold","ci95":[0.000481,0.004794],"class":"experimental_unspecified","entry":"value_types/LATTICE_LENGTH/classes/experimental_unspecified","floor":0.0013,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":9,"prior_source":"orchid_assumed","value":0.004293},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":3.3024,"value_stored":0.33024},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"kind":"unknown","label":"1964Val","status":"unresolved"},{"kind":"unknown","label":"1965Car","status":"unresolved"},{"kind":"unknown","label":"1976Kat","status":"unresolved"},{"kind":"unknown","label":"1978Min","status":"unresolved"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"HF-NB","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"before":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"phases","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}},{"after":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_08","doi":"10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","pdf_page":6,"pdf_sha256":"16df47145c84a0b30f7171a6666874a54999828b39daf4e55ca659e77b089203","printed":"Element Nb block, row Structure 'BCC (A2)' | 0.32929 | 0.33024 [b] (footnote b: at 4.2 K)","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies phase, strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[7,8,12,13],"table":"1","table_key":"t143"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 08","image_sha256":"ffb7620b74e2e0c5007cd275e4ec34e1413cce2d3a96c0a1d5521627d83aac8b","page":6,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"16df47145c84a0b3","seen":"Nb block BCC row; r8, r12, r13 are three readings of the same Expt. value 0.33024 (r13 carries T=298.15 while footnote [b] says 4.2 K)","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-UNIJCMOWJX","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1","row":13},"observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","paper":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7","phases":[{"label":"BCC","label_source":"printed_source_page"}],"pid":"doi:10.1016/s0364-5916(02)80003-7/p6/tab-1/r13#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"single_reader","reader_agreement_label":"unconfirmed (single reader)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"HF-NB","structure":{"phase":"BCC","strukturbericht":"A2"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":298.15,"temperature_basis":"assumed_room_temperature","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.007265,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.001793,0.002549],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/LATTICE_LENGTH/classes/unknown","floor":0.0022,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":586,"value":0.007265},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":3.3024,"value_stored":0.33024},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["C15"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-VP4N3BXPZU","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":11},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"C15"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r11#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔfH","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"ZR":{"phase":"HCP_A3"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.8165},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":16.33,"value_printed":16.33,"value_stored":16330.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["C15"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-I7XQX62O3B","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":11},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"C15"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r11#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"a","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.3835},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0767,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0767},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":7.67,"value_printed":7.67,"value_stored":7.67},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ2"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-JPJ7SORJML","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":23},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ2"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r23#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔfH","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"ZR":{"phase":"HCP_A3"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.7755},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":15.51,"value_printed":15.51,"value_stored":15510.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ2"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"537e6fa1d1e99d97651c2abbb300579e7941841d1c1e8d7b2485dfffdf57551b","printed":"Group label 'τ2 (C14)' on the first row (ZrFe2 -27.73 4.97/8.10); continuation rows ZrFe2 ... FeNb2 60.01 5.42/8.59","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[14,15,16,17,18,19,20,22,23,24,25,26,27,28],"table":"2","table_key":"t012"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"56d6a652a76c9e950ffd033b255b5486f93edf155239942842410a0909c2bf21","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"537e6fa1d1e99d97","seen":"τ2 group from ZrFe2 -27.73 to FeNb2 60.01; ends before the C36 label (ZrFe2 -28.55). Phase already τ2.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DKKEJZUUWC.6a77ff","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":23},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ2"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r23#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"a","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","structure":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.274},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0548,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0548},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":5.48,"value_printed":5.48,"value_stored":5.48},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ2"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"537e6fa1d1e99d97651c2abbb300579e7941841d1c1e8d7b2485dfffdf57551b","printed":"Group label 'τ2 (C14)' on the first row (ZrFe2 -27.73 4.97/8.10); continuation rows ZrFe2 ... FeNb2 60.01 5.42/8.59","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[14,15,16,17,18,19,20,22,23,24,25,26,27,28],"table":"2","table_key":"t012"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"56d6a652a76c9e950ffd033b255b5486f93edf155239942842410a0909c2bf21","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"537e6fa1d1e99d97","seen":"τ2 group from ZrFe2 -27.73 to FeNb2 60.01; ends before the C36 label (ZrFe2 -28.55). Phase already τ2.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DKKEJZUUWC.e5f9a9","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":23},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ2"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r23#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"c","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","structure":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.433},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0866,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0866},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":8.66,"value_printed":8.66,"value_stored":8.66},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","first_author":"Liu","kind":"assessment","label":"44","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","reference":"S.H. Liu, B. Hallstedt, D. Music, Y. Du, CALPHAD 38 (2012) 43–58.","status":"resolved","year":"2012"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"dft","before":"model","evidence":{"T_K":0.0,"caption":"Comparison of enthalpies of formation for the end-member compounds between VASP calculations in the present work and data from the literature in the Zr-Fe-Nb sy","method":null},"field":"evidence_class","gate":"R2","rule":"first_principles_row_of_mixed_table","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-24","image_sha256":"1c7e9a0ec5234fb4aa3b989ba9037a95ee34c0f73ecd6034504d85ad58ded669","page":4,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ce7f08d514f677ab","seen":"Rows of first-principles tables whose printed method is a DFT code, or 0 K values without a CALPHAD / assessed / optimised label, are DFT results.","verdict":"rule_confirmed"}},{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ2"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","evidence_class_before_gates":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-LJNTBA25GL","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":24},"model_unlinked_reason":"reporting paper's own calculation, but no TDB linked to the table","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"model_value","class_gate":"dft","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ2"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r24#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔfH","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"ZR":{"phase":"HCP_A3"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.827},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":16.54,"value_printed":16.54,"value_stored":16540.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","first_author":"Liu","kind":"assessment","label":"44","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","reference":"S.H. Liu, B. Hallstedt, D. Music, Y. Du, CALPHAD 38 (2012) 43–58.","status":"resolved","year":"2012"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ2"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"537e6fa1d1e99d97651c2abbb300579e7941841d1c1e8d7b2485dfffdf57551b","printed":"Group label 'τ2 (C14)' on the first row (ZrFe2 -27.73 4.97/8.10); continuation rows ZrFe2 ... FeNb2 60.01 5.42/8.59","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[14,15,16,17,18,19,20,22,23,24,25,26,27,28],"table":"2","table_key":"t012"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"56d6a652a76c9e950ffd033b255b5486f93edf155239942842410a0909c2bf21","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"537e6fa1d1e99d97","seen":"τ2 group from ZrFe2 -27.73 to FeNb2 60.01; ends before the C36 label (ZrFe2 -28.55). Phase already τ2.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-HP7LKAIO36.722977","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":24},"model_unlinked_reason":"reporting paper's own calculation, but no TDB linked to the table","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ2"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r24#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"c","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","structure":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.4435},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0683,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.005826,0.012707],"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.0077,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":175,"value":0.0683},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":8.87,"value_printed":8.87,"value_stored":8.87},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","first_author":"Liu","kind":"assessment","label":"44","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","reference":"S.H. Liu, B. Hallstedt, D. Music, Y. Du, CALPHAD 38 (2012) 43–58.","status":"resolved","year":"2012"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ2"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"before":null,"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"537e6fa1d1e99d97651c2abbb300579e7941841d1c1e8d7b2485dfffdf57551b","printed":"Group label 'τ2 (C14)' on the first row (ZrFe2 -27.73 4.97/8.10); continuation rows ZrFe2 ... FeNb2 60.01 5.42/8.59","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[14,15,16,17,18,19,20,22,23,24,25,26,27,28],"table":"2","table_key":"t012"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"56d6a652a76c9e950ffd033b255b5486f93edf155239942842410a0909c2bf21","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"537e6fa1d1e99d97","seen":"τ2 group from ZrFe2 -27.73 to FeNb2 60.01; ends before the C36 label (ZrFe2 -28.55). Phase already τ2.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-HP7LKAIO36.e203fc","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":24},"model_unlinked_reason":"reporting paper's own calculation, but no TDB linked to the table","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2012.03.004","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ2"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r24#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"a","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","structure":{"phase":"τ2","strukturbericht":"C14"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.2735},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.04212,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.005826,0.012707],"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.0077,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":175,"value":0.04212},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":5.47,"value_printed":5.47,"value_stored":5.47},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["C36"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-QPY5EUJQIE","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":36},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"C36"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r36#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔfH","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"ZR":{"phase":"HCP_A3"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.8055},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":16.11,"value_printed":16.11,"value_stored":16110.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["C36"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-W5IQTFOFIL.0ed993","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":36},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"C36"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r36#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"c","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.8735},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.1747,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.1747},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":17.47,"value_printed":17.47,"value_stored":17.47},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["C36"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-W5IQTFOFIL.4982b8","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":36},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"C36"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r36#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"a","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.273},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0546,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0546},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":5.46,"value_printed":5.46,"value_stored":5.46},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ1"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-WMNNRHBATQ","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":56},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ1"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r56#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔfH","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"}},"reference_state_stored":{"FE":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"NB":{"phase":"BCC_A2"},"ZR":{"phase":"HCP_A3"}},"source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":1.273},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":25.46,"value_printed":25.46,"value_stored":25460.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"FE-NB-ZR","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"phases":["τ1"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-A25PIUEQ52","locator":{"ref":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2","row":56},"method":"VASP","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"ZR":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2017.05.008","phases":[{"label":"τ1"}],"pid":"sha256:537e6fa1d1e99d97/p3/tab-2/r56#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","property_printed":"a","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"FE-NB-ZR","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.6105},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.1221,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.1221},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_printed":"Å","unit_stored":"Å","value":12.21,"value_printed":12.21,"value_stored":12.21},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"first_author":"Villars","kind":"assessment","label":"9","reference":"Villars P, Calvert LD, editors. Pearson’s handbook of crystallographic data for intermetallic phases, 2nd ed. Materials Park, OH: ASM International; 1991.","status":"resolved","year":"1991"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"AL-NB-SI","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"SI":0.0},"phases":["Nb"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":0,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-JUPAVL22EC","locator":{"ref":"sha256:817d4718c6006e4b/p2/tab-1","row":2},"model_unlinked_reason":"reporting paper's own calculation, but no TDB linked to the table","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"cited_reference_is_assessment","class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"SI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2004.03.011","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.intermet.2004.03.011","phases":[{"label":"Nb"}],"pid":"sha256:817d4718c6006e4b/p2/tab-1/r02#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"AL-NB-SI","structure":{"pearson_symbol":"cI2","prototype":"A2"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":298.15,"temperature_basis":"assumed_room_temperature","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":5e-05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.02546,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.005826,0.012707],"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.0077,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":175,"value":0.02546},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":5e-05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":3.3067,"value_stored":0.33067},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"AL-FE-MO-NB-SN-TA-V","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"FE":0.0,"MO":0.0,"NB":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TA":0.0,"V":0.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"judge_adjudicated":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:computation_context","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-IZ2G2ZLA7X","locator":{"ref":"sha256:89569ecc2a43917d/p5/tab-4","row":3},"method":"DFT (QE-USPP)","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"FE":0.0,"MO":0.0,"NB":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TA":0.0,"V":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","phases":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"pid":"sha256:89569ecc2a43917d/p5/tab-4/r03#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"GIBBS_ENERGY","property_group":"activity / EMF / Gibbs energy","property_printed":"Gm(ω)-Gm(β)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude+fable_judge","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"AL-FE-MO-NB-SN-TA-V","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":963.35},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":7200.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/G_MIX_PARTIAL","floor":7.2,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol","value":7200.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.5},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"J/mol","value_type":"G_MIX_PARTIAL"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"J/mol","unit_basis":"column_header","unit_printed":"J/mol","value":19267.0,"value_printed":19267},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"AL-FE-MO-NB-SN-TA-V","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"FE":0.0,"MO":0.0,"NB":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TA":0.0,"V":0.0},"phases":["UNKNOWN"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","row_state":"disputed_normalization_only","specification_gaps":["state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":2,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-4V34BQFPHS","locator":{"ref":"sha256:89569ecc2a43917d/p5/tab-4","row":4},"method":"CALPHAD","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","model_unlinked_reason":"reporting paper's own calculation, but no TDB linked to the table","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_names_calculation","class":"model_value","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"FE":0.0,"MO":0.0,"NB":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TA":0.0,"V":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.jallcom.2016.02.251","phases":[{"label":"UNKNOWN"}],"pid":"sha256:89569ecc2a43917d/p5/tab-4/r04#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"GIBBS_ENERGY","property_group":"activity / EMF / Gibbs energy","property_printed":"Gm(ω)-Gm(β)","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"AL-FE-MO-NB-SN-TA-V","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"printed","temperature_printed":"0 K","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":343.9},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":1000.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","ci95":null,"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/G_MIX_PARTIAL","floor":1.0,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol","n_pairs":94,"value":1000.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.5},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"J/mol","value_type":"G_MIX_PARTIAL"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"J/mol","unit_basis":"column_header","unit_printed":"J/mol","value":6878.0,"value_printed":6878},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"first_author":"Daams","kind":"assessment","label":"11","reference":"J.L.C. Daams, P. Villars, J.H.N. van Vucht, Pearson's Handbook of Crystallographic Data for Intermetallic Phase, ASM International, Metals Park, OH, 1991.","status":"resolved","year":"1991"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"NB-SI-W","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":{"SI":0.0,"W":0.0},"phases":["Nb"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"model","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":0,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-5WCAHYLZPW","locator":{"ref":"sha256:a43bd9e453a91e6b/p2/tab-1","row":1},"model_unlinked_reason":"reporting paper's own calculation, but no TDB linked to the table","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"cited_reference_is_assessment","class":"model_value","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"SI":0.0,"W":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.04.004","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2013.04.004","phases":[{"label":"Nb"}],"pid":"sha256:a43bd9e453a91e6b/p2/tab-1/r01#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"NB-SI-W","structure":{"pearson_symbol":"cI2","prototype":"W"},"system":"NB","temperature_K":298.15,"temperature_basis":"assumed_room_temperature","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.05},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.005826,0.012707],"class":"model_calculated","entry":"model/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.0077,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":175,"value":0.02541},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"nm","value":3.3,"value_stored":0.33},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"own_work_origin_unspecified"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["Nonmagnetic BCC Nb"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"unspecified","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["state:T_K_explicit","temperature not stated"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-ECH7WVIK42","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-1","row":3},"observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work_kind_unstated","class":"unspecified","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"Nonmagnetic BCC Nb"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-1/r03#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","system":"NB","temperature_basis":"not_printed","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.007304,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.001793,0.002549],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/LATTICE_LENGTH/classes/unknown","floor":0.0022,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":586,"value":0.007304},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"pm","value":3.32,"value_stored":332.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"first_author":"Villars","kind":"assessment","label":"2","reference":"P. Villars, L.D. Calvert, Pearson’s Handbook of Crystallographic Data for Intermetallic Phases, ASM International, Materials Park, OH, USA, 1991.","status":"resolved","year":"1991"}],"conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["Nonmagnetic BCC Nb"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-VGM6XLA57K","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-1","row":4},"observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_experimental","class":"experimental","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"Nonmagnetic BCC Nb"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-1/r04#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","system":"NB","temperature_K":298.15,"temperature_basis":"assumed_room_temperature","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[0.001793,0.002549],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/LATTICE_LENGTH/classes/unknown","floor":0.0022,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","n_pairs":586,"value":0.00726},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"pm","value":3.3,"value_stored":330.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Column-group header 'C14' (upper block): Cr2Cr 464 766 1.191 ... CrTa2 532 850 1.740","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"9 rows of the upper block, C14 columns; phase already C14","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-H44DNK52J2.5e11d0","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":2},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r02#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V_ATOM","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05682,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.05682},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"10^7 pm^3","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"10^7 pm^3","value":1.894},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Column-group header 'C14' (upper block): Cr2Cr 464 766 1.191 ... CrTa2 532 850 1.740","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"9 rows of the upper block, C14 columns; phase already C14","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-H44DNK52J2.7a6a97","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":2},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r02#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.055,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.055},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"pm","value":5.5,"value_stored":550.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Column-group header 'C14' (upper block): Cr2Cr 464 766 1.191 ... CrTa2 532 850 1.740","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"9 rows of the upper block, C14 columns; phase already C14","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-H44DNK52J2.e486d8","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":2},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r02#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C14","strukturbericht":"C14","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0868,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0868},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"pm","value":8.68,"value_stored":868.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C15"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C15","strukturbericht":"C15","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Column-group header 'C15' (upper block): Cr2Cr 658 1.187 ... CrTa2 748 1.744","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"same 9 row labels, C15 columns; phase already C15","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DPTRJGP2ZM.670a49","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":11},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C15"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r11#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C15","strukturbericht":"C15","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0769,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0769},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"pm","value":7.69,"value_stored":769.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C15"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C15","strukturbericht":"C15","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Column-group header 'C15' (upper block): Cr2Cr 658 1.187 ... CrTa2 748 1.744","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"same 9 row labels, C15 columns; phase already C15","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-DPTRJGP2ZM.fd5c9e","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":11},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C15"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r11#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_V_ATOM","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C15","strukturbericht":"C15","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.05694,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.05694},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"10^7 pm^3","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"10^7 pm^3","value":1.898},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C36"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C36","strukturbericht":"C36","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Lower block column-group header 'C36': Cr2Cr 465 1523 2.378 ... CrTa2 530 1718 3.486","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[19,20,21,22,23,24,25],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"7 rows of the lower block; phase already C36","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-LZI7235JYJ.583aa6","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":20},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C36"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r20#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_A","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C36","strukturbericht":"C36","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.0548,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.0548},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"pm","value":5.48,"value_stored":548.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C36"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C36","strukturbericht":"C36","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Lower block column-group header 'C36': Cr2Cr 465 1523 2.378 ... CrTa2 530 1718 3.486","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[19,20,21,22,23,24,25],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"7 rows of the lower block; phase already C36","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-LZI7235JYJ.60c6da","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":20},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C36"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r20#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_2V_ATOM","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C36","strukturbericht":"C36","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.1139,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/VOLUME","floor":0.03,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.1139},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.0005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"10^7 pm^3","value_type":"VOLUME"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"10^7 pm^3","value":3.796},{"chemical_system":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C36"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"},{"after":{"phase":"C36","strukturbericht":"C36","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"before":{"v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"evidence":{"batch":"table_context_batch_01","doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","pdf_page":3,"pdf_sha256":"ade531b1c8f06a5c7057ba555a7d41c6e21e10e9a887701198d2dbc4bce10498","printed":"Lower block column-group header 'C36': Cr2Cr 465 1523 2.378 ... CrTa2 530 1718 3.486","rationale":"Printed table context for this group supplies strukturbericht; shared fields only, row values, references, uncertainty, composition and conditions unchanged; no forward fill across groups and no inference from symmetry, composition or other papers.","report_id":"ORCHID-TC-20261027-v1","source_group_rows":[19,20,21,22,23,24,25],"table":"2","table_key":"t016"},"field":"structure","gate":"TC20261027","rule":"source_adjudicated_table_context","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-27; Claude rendered-page inspection, table-context batch 01","image_sha256":"b1e94793f6efd4cb7b38b1f0684e6a656a85b4748105f8ee4c4a76f07dfdbdef","page":3,"pdf_sha256_prefix":"ade531b1c8f06a5c","seen":"7 rows of the lower block; phase already C36","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["table_context_correction_requires_downstream_revalidation"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-LZI7235JYJ.e0174c","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2","row":20},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"structural_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C36"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-2/r20#structural_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"LATTICE_C","property_group":"crystal structure","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.1-pro-preview","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","source_system":"CR-NB-TA","structure":{"phase":"C36","strukturbericht":"C36","v71_only_unconfirmed":{"designation":"Nb2Nb"}},"system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"reading_resolution","value":0.0005},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":0.1752,"sigma_method":{"basis":"prior","class":"dft","entry":"dft/priors/LATTICE_LENGTH","floor":0.01,"floor_unit":"relative (fraction of the value)","value":0.1752},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"Å","value_type":"LATTICE_LENGTH"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"Å","unit_stored":"pm","value":17.52,"value_stored":1752.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","component":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-Q4O5P4FJO2","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3","row":3},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3/r03#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔE0L-SER","reader_agreement":"single_reader_text_layer","reader_agreement_label":"single reader + PDF text layer","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"TA":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"source_system":"CR-NB-TA","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (the quantity is defined at 0 K)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.7685},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ mol⁻¹","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":15.37,"value_printed":15.37,"value_stored":15370.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","first_author":"Sluiter","kind":"assessment","label":"26","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","reference":"M.H.F. Sluiter, CALPHAD 30 (2006) 357.","status":"resolved","year":"2006"}],"component":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C14"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:computation_context"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-ZBR63TSLH6","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3","row":4},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"computed","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C14"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3/r04#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔE0L-SER","reader_agreement":"single_reader_text_layer","reader_agreement_label":"single reader + PDF text layer","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"TA":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"source_system":"CR-NB-TA","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (the quantity is defined at 0 K)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.77},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ mol⁻¹","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":15.4,"value_printed":15.4,"value_stored":15400.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","component":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C15"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-BUN2NLZL3O","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3","row":9},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C15"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3/r09#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔE0L-SER","reader_agreement":"single_reader_text_layer","reader_agreement_label":"single reader + PDF text layer","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"TA":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"source_system":"CR-NB-TA","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (the quantity is defined at 0 K)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.81},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ mol⁻¹","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":16.2,"value_printed":16.2,"value_stored":16200.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","cited_sources":[{"doi":"10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","first_author":"Sluiter","kind":"assessment","label":"26","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2006.09.002","reference":"M.H.F. Sluiter, CALPHAD 30 (2006) 357.","status":"resolved","year":"2006"}],"component":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"cited_source","note":"conditions in the cited source"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C15"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:computation_context"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-D5PG2AZXCM","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3","row":10},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"printed_source_other_calculation","class":"computed","own_work_of_paper":false},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C15"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3/r10#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔE0L-SER","reader_agreement":"single_reader_text_layer","reader_agreement_label":"single reader + PDF text layer","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"TA":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"source_system":"CR-NB-TA","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (the quantity is defined at 0 K)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.81},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ mol⁻¹","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":16.2,"value_printed":16.2,"value_stored":16200.0},{"chemical_system":"NB","component":"NB","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"NB","before":"CR-NB-TA","evidence":{"basis":"overall_composition_all_elements","overall_composition":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"phases":["C36"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":3,"fold_lso":4,"id":"ORC-R77HCY7WY6","locator":{"ref":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3","row":14},"method":"ab initio","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":{"NB":1.0},"overall_composition_basis":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NB":1.0,"TA":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.calphad.2008.04.006","phases":[{"label":"C36"}],"pid":"sha256:ade531b1c8f06a5c/p3/tab-3/r14#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"ΔE0L-SER","reader_agreement":"single_reader_text_layer","reader_agreement_label":"single reader + PDF text layer","reader_tier":"confirmed_pro","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"reference_state_stored":{"CR":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"NB":{"phase":"printed:SER"},"TA":{"phase":"printed:SER"}},"source_system":"CR-NB-TA","system":"NB","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (the quantity is defined at 0 K)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.7985},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":8.395,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[6.672,9.877],"class":"dft","entry":"dft/literature/strata/metal","floor":8.395,"floor_unit":"kJ/mol-atom","n_pairs":230,"stratum":"literature/metal","value":8.395},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.005},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","value_type":"HM_FORM"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","unit_basis":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ mol⁻¹","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":15.97,"value_printed":15.97,"value_stored":15970.0}],"release":"orchid-literature 2026-10-23 (record store db-v2.1: invariant/general v2.1.19r, text+context fixup-20261022)","system":"NB"}