{"artifacts":{"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042/p4/text-38":{"artifact":"text_passage","label":"page 4, passage 38","page":4},"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3":{"artifact":"table","caption":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects in the Heusler and the half Heusler calculated in Ti-Ni-Sn, Hf-Ni-Sn compared to those published earlier into brackets [3,5]. In the Heusler structure, the 4c and 4d sites are gathered into the 8c site. The most stable defects are in bold.","label":"3","page":5}},"cite_as":{"also_cite":["the original source of every value you use (paper_citation / paper_doi, and cited_dois for values the paper cites from earlier work)"],"bibtex":"@misc{orchid_literature_2026,\n  author    = {Arr{\\'o}yave, Raymundo and Saal, James and Shin, Dongwon},\n  title     = {{ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature}},\n  version   = {2026.10},\n  publisher = {Zenodo},\n  year      = {2026},\n  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23735569},\n  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569},\n  note      = {Version 1, machine-extracted}\n}","dataset":"literature","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23735569","license":"CC-BY-4.0","part_of":{"bibtex":"@misc{orchid_data_2026,\n  author    = {Arr{\\'o}yave, Raymundo and Saal, James and Shin, Dongwon},\n  title     = {{ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets}},\n  version   = {2026.10},\n  publisher = {Zenodo},\n  year      = {2026},\n  doi       = {10.5281/zenodo.23736065},\n  url       = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065},\n  note      = {Version 1, machine-extracted}\n}","doi":"10.5281/zenodo.23736065","text":"R. Arróyave, J. Saal, D. Shin, ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets (version 2026.10; Version 1, machine-extracted), Zenodo (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065","title":"ORCHID data: umbrella record of the ORCHID datasets","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23736065"},"release_tag":"v2026.10","status":"Version 1, machine-extracted: values were read by language-model readers constrained to quote their source and checked automatically, and the release was then audited on the printed pages by adversarial audits, an independent second review of fit-facing records and a preliminary human review of a frozen sample. Flags such as accepted and ESPEI-ready record screening results, not certification; known issues are listed in the release notes.","text":"R. Arróyave, J. Saal, D. Shin, ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature (version 2026.10; Version 1, machine-extracted), Zenodo (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569","title":"ORCHID-Values: thermodynamic and phase-equilibrium values read from the literature","url":"https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23735569","version":"2026.10"},"contexts":{},"elements":["NI","SN","TI"],"licence":"CC BY 4.0 (ORCHID data; quotes are short excerpts kept for verification, the publishers' copyright, not relicensed)","models":{},"note":"records[].locator.ref -> artifacts; records[].model -> models (full records: orchid-literature.jsonl.gz)","papers":{"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042":{"authors":["A. Berche","J.C. Tédenac","P. Jund"],"citation":"A. Berche, J.C. Tédenac, P. Jund, Phase diagram and enthalpy of formation of Hf-Ni-Sn, Computational Materials Science 125, 271-277 (2016).","container":"Computational Materials Science","doi":"10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","doi_url":"https://doi.org/10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","kind":"corpus_paper","metadata_source":"crossref","pdf_sha256_prefix":"864a974ee9a34cd4","roles":["cited_source","reporting_paper"],"source_kinds":["journal_article"],"title":"Phase diagram and enthalpy of formation of Hf-Ni-Sn","year":2016}},"part":1,"parts":1,"records":[{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"magnitude_suspect":false,"magnitude_suspect_before_page_fix":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["basis per formula unit (inferred)","reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-3J4HV2RD6E.a3092c","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":1},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r01#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":20.185},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":403.7,"value_printed":403.7,"value_stored":403700.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-3J4HV2RD6E.cd21bf","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":1},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r01#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":6.265},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":125.3,"value_printed":125.3,"value_stored":125300.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-AVP4BLDVG5.5630f5","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":2},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r02#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":10.665},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":213.3,"value_printed":213.3,"value_stored":213300.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-AVP4BLDVG5.b33a89","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":2},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r02#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.815},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":-16.3,"value_printed":-16.3,"value_stored":-16300.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.5,"SN":0.25,"TI":0.25},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":null,"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-OQGVR2JUYV.5e7f85","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":3},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":null,"overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.5,"SN":0.25,"TI":0.25},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r03#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":3.85},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":77.0,"value_printed":77.0,"value_stored":77000.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":null,"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-OQGVR2JUYV.7b8dbc","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":3},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":null,"overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r03#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":14.305},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":286.1,"value_printed":286.1,"value_stored":286100.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.5,"SN":0.25,"TI":0.25},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":null,"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-KKAFA5BPXA.637556","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":4},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":null,"overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.5,"SN":0.25,"TI":0.25},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r04#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":4.45},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":89.0,"value_printed":89.0,"value_stored":89000.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":null,"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"magnitude_suspect":false,"magnitude_suspect_before_page_fix":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["basis per formula unit (inferred)","reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-KKAFA5BPXA.76a075","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":4},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":null,"overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r04#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":15.38},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":307.6,"value_printed":307.6,"value_stored":307600.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-LDAYZNGOPU.2ef513","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":5},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r05#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":9.055},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":181.1,"value_printed":181.1,"value_stored":181100.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-LDAYZNGOPU.d63d2a","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":5},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r05#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":10.08},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":201.6,"value_printed":201.6,"value_stored":201600.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-TH5BPDLPA2.6a36a7","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":6},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r06#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":14.485},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":289.7,"value_printed":289.7,"value_stored":289700.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-TH5BPDLPA2.b72a54","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":6},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r06#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":5.855},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":117.1,"value_printed":117.1,"value_stored":117100.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-J6FFOCJ36C.2933d1","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":7},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r07#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":7.865},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":157.3,"value_printed":157.3,"value_stored":157300.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-J6FFOCJ36C.d36836","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":7},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r07#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":0.135},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":2.7,"value_printed":2.7,"value_stored":2700.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-EYH2TUTHTZ.71d4bc","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":8},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r08#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":4.21},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":84.2,"value_printed":84.2,"value_stored":84200.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"magnitude_suspect":false,"magnitude_suspect_before_page_fix":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["basis per formula unit (inferred)","reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-EYH2TUTHTZ.da8c61","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":8},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r08#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":20.92},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":418.4,"value_printed":418.4,"value_stored":418400.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.5,"SN":0.25,"TI":0.25},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":null,"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNi2Sn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-D7CNPHBOMT.782a18","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":9},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":null,"overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.5,"SN":0.25,"TI":0.25},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNi2Sn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r09#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":12.025},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":240.5,"value_printed":240.5,"value_stored":240500.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":null,"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"magnitude_suspect":false,"magnitude_suspect_before_page_fix":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["basis per formula unit (inferred)","reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-D7CNPHBOMT.870887","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":9},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":null,"overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r09#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":18.775},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":375.5,"value_printed":375.5,"value_stored":375500.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":null,"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-LBCEJBDSO4.ff4204","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":10},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":null,"overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.333333,"SN":0.333333,"TI":0.333333},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r10#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":9.185},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":183.7,"value_printed":183.7,"value_stored":183700.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-LLPCIIVZFK.de0dc0","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":11},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":1.0,"SN":0.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r11#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":3.98},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":79.6,"value_printed":79.6,"value_stored":79600.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"not_applicable_own_calculation"},"corrections":[{"after":"kJ/mol-defect","before":"kJ/mol (basis unstated)","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","before":"HM_FORM","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"property","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":null,"before":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","before":"from_formula","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"overall_composition_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","before":"unstated","evidence":{"printed":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions."},"field":"unit_basis","gate":"page","rule":"source_page_cross_dataset_review","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"corrected"}},{"after":"NI-SN-TI","before":"HF-NI-SN-TI","evidence":{"basis":"phase_formula","overall_composition":null,"phases":["TiNiSn"]},"field":"system","gate":"A1","rule":"system_of_the_state"}],"evidence_class":"dft","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":true,"gate_failures":["defect_energy_not_a_formation_property"],"magnitude_suspect":false,"magnitude_suspect_before_page_fix":true,"review_state":"extracted","specification_gaps":["basis per formula unit (inferred)","reference-dependent quantity without a resolved reference state","state:reference_state"],"state_fully_specified":false,"system_is_state_subsystem":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"defect_energy_not_a_formation_property","detail":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","effect":"not_espei_ready","gate":"page","visual_check":{"checked":"2026-10-25","image_sha256":"f7046cbbf8326146cfda10f72d75effec7c8e516ae25cc24a5cadab9f221a6c7","page":5,"seen":"Table 3: enthalpy of formation of defects (kJ/mol/defects). TiNiSn, HfNiSn, TiNi2Sn, HfNi2Sn are host phases; their defective-cell compositions are not given as normalized bulk fractions.","verdict":"confirmed"}}],"id":"ORC-IEUVTOLMNL.f66269","locator":{"ref":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3","row":12},"method":"DFT","method_basis":"printed in the table row/column","observation_type":"equilibrium_property","origin":{"basis":"this_work+label_first_principles","class":"computed","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"overall_composition":null,"overall_composition_basis":"host phase printed; defective-cell composition not specified","overall_composition_basis_stored":"from_formula","overall_composition_stored":{"NI":0.0,"SN":1.0,"TI":0.0},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","phases":[{"label":"TiNiSn"}],"pid":"sha256:864a974ee9a34cd4/p5/tab-3/r12#equilibrium_property","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"unstated_assumed","property":"DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","property_code_before_gates":"HM_FORM","property_group":"formation","property_printed":"Enthalpy of formation of the defects","reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash+claude","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash","text_layer"],"record_kind":"general_table","reference_state":{"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"reference_state_stored":{"HF":{"phase":"printed:none"},"NI":{"phase":"printed:none"},"SN":{"phase":"printed:none"},"TI":{"phase":"printed:none"}},"source_system":"HF-NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":0.0,"temperature_basis":"quantity_label","temperature_printed":"0 K (static calculation)","tool_release":"tools-release-v2.1.18","uncertainty":{"basis":"stated_default","note":"5% default","value":19.74},"uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":null,"sigma_effective_reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","sigma_method":{"reason":"no method floor defined for property DEFECT_FORMATION_ENERGY","value":null},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","value_type":null}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"kJ/mol-defect","unit_basis":"per_mole_of_defects_printed","unit_basis_stored":"unstated","unit_printed":"kJ/mol/defects","unit_stored":"J/mol (basis unstated)","value":394.8,"value_printed":394.8,"value_stored":394800.0},{"chemical_system":"NI-SN-TI","conditions":{"kind":"paper_context_not_extracted","paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042"},"evidence_class":"experimental","flags":{"calphad_check":"not_available","espei_certified":false,"espei_ready":false,"extraction_accepted":false,"gate_failures":["state_phases_missing"],"review_flags":["NOTE_SELF_FLAG"],"review_state":"extracted","second_reader":"done","value_in_quote":true},"fold_lpo":4,"fold_lso":2,"gate_failures":[{"code":"state_phases_missing","detail":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE without the phases of its state (not_a_single_phase_transition)","effect":"not_accepted","gate":"R3"}],"id":"ORC-CIPFBHD377","link_rule":"quote verbatim on one page/passage + printed value inside quote","locator":{"ref":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042/p4/text-38"},"observation_type":"phase_transition","origin":{"attribution_note":"no printed citation: the paper's own statement","class":"experimental","measured_in":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","own_work_of_paper":true},"paper":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","paper_id":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042","pid":"doi:10.1016/j.commatsci.2016.08.042/p4/text-38/s17#phase_transition","pressure_Pa":101325,"pressure_basis":"assumed_default_1_atm_not_printed","pressure_basis_stored":"stated_default_1_atm","property":"TRANSITION_TEMPERATURE","property_group":"phase transition","quote":"In Ti-Ni-Sn, the most stable phase is the Heusler and the half decomposes around 1400 K.","quote_page":4,"reaction":{"type":"other"},"reader_agreement":"multi_reader","reader_agreement_basis":"derived_from_readers","reader_agreement_label":"confirmed (two or more readers)","reader_tier":"preliminary_flash","readers":["claude-opus-5.5","gemini-3.8-flash"],"record_kind":"running_text","source_system":"NI-SN-TI","system":"NI-SN-TI","temperature_K":1400.0,"temperature_printed":"1400 K","tool_release":"release v2 + tools dev copy record build","transition_kind":"other","transition_kind_printed":"other","uncertainty_budget":{"calibration":"orchid-uncertainty-calibration 2026-10-24 (audit round 2) sha256 6a2b5a92b0ec","quantities":{"value":{"sigma_composition":null,"sigma_conversion":null,"sigma_effective":16.0,"sigma_method":{"basis":"calibrated","ci95":[10.483565,26.208913],"class":"unknown","entry":"value_types/T_TRANSITION/classes/unknown","floor":16.0,"floor_unit":"K","n_pairs":274,"value":16.0},"sigma_printed":null,"sigma_reading":{"basis":"last_printed_digit","value":0.05},"sigma_scatter":null,"unit":"K","value_type":"T_TRANSITION"}},"sigma_rule":"max(sqrt(max(printed, reading, method)^2 + composition^2 + conversion^2), scatter)"},"unit":"K","value":1400.0}],"release":"orchid-literature 2026-10-23 (record store db-v2.1: invariant/general v2.1.19r, text+context fixup-20261022)","system":"NI-SN-TI"}